Research Summary
Three Provisions That Settle the Question
The standard ISO Personal Auto Policy states that the insurer has no duty to provide coverage under the policy unless there has been full compliance with the duties listed, the first being that “We must be notified promptly of how, when and where the accident or loss happened,” including the names and addresses of any injured persons and of any witnesses.[1]
California Insurance Code § 1861.02(a) limits auto rating to the insured’s driving safety record, annual mileage, years of driving experience and factors the commissioner adopts by regulation.[4] Title 10 of the California Code of Regulations § 2632.13(b) treats a driver as principally at fault only where the driver’s actions or omissions were at least 51 percent of the legal cause of the accident.[8]
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau describes LexisNexis C.L.U.E. as collecting and reporting up to seven years of auto insurance claims to help inform pricing and underwriting decisions for the insurance industry.[10] The Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner states that if your insurance company starts, denies or pays out a claim, it will submit a C.L.U.E. report — a trigger that does not depend on which driver made the call.[9]
The Sentence in Your Policy That Decides This
Open the policy your carrier mailed you and find Part E. Nearly every personal auto contract in the United States is built on a common template — the Insurance Services Office Personal Auto Policy, form PP 00 01, which state regulators publish for public inspection. Part E is titled Duties After An Accident Or Loss, and it opens with a conditional rather than a request.
Policy Text — ISO Form PP 00 01, Part E
“We have no duty to provide coverage under this policy unless there has been full compliance with the following duties: A. We must be notified promptly of how, when and where the accident or loss happened. Notice should also include the names and addresses of any injured persons and of any witnesses.”[1]
Read the grammar rather than the tone. The clause is drafted as a condition precedent: coverage is not promised and then withdrawn for misbehavior — it is promised only on the condition that the duties were met. How much that drafting actually buys the insurer is a question of state law rather than of the form. Whether a notice clause is enforced as a true condition precedent, and whether the insurer must show that the late report prejudiced its investigation before it can deny on that ground, varies from state to state. Every argument about whether a late report “should” cost you coverage runs into that structure first and into your state’s notice-prejudice rule second. Those notice rules, and the separate statutes of limitations for suing, are compared in our report on whether there is a time limit on car insurance claims.
Now read what is missing. The sentence names three facts the insurer must receive — how, when, where — and two categories of people. It does not name fault. It does not condition the duty on whether you intend to claim anything. A driver who was rear-ended at a red light owes exactly the same notice as the driver who did the rear-ending, because the trigger is the occurrence of an accident or loss and nothing else.
The reason the duty is written that way becomes obvious three paragraphs later, in the duties attached specifically to physical damage coverage. A person seeking Coverage For Damage To Your Auto must take reasonable steps after loss to protect the vehicle from further loss, must promptly notify the police if the vehicle is stolen, and must permit the insurer to inspect and appraise the damaged property before its repair or disposal.[1] That last duty has a physical deadline built into it. Damaged sheet metal is evidence, and a body shop’s first act is to destroy that evidence by disassembling and replacing it.
So the mechanism behind the word “promptly” is not punishment. It is sequence. Notice arrives, the carrier gets its inspection window, the inspection fixes the damage in the record, and the record is what the carrier later uses to prove to the other side what its insured’s vehicle actually looked like. Skip the first step and every step behind it collapses — which is the concrete prejudice an insurer points to when it argues that a late report cost it the ability to investigate.
There is one more duty in Part E that reads like boilerplate and matters enormously in a not-at-fault crash: a person seeking coverage must cooperate with the insurer in the investigation, settlement or defense of any claim or suit, promptly send copies of any notices or legal papers received in connection with the accident, and submit, as often as the insurer reasonably requires, to examination under oath.[1] Notice the pronoun. The cooperation you owe is owed to us— your carrier. The other driver’s adjuster, however pleasant, is outside that sentence entirely.
The Fear That Drives the Question, Measured Against the Statutes
The premium worry is not irrational. Carriers do price claim history, and a loss event in your file is a loss event. What most drivers do not know is that in a meaningful set of states, the legislature has already decided that a driver who did not cause a crash may not be charged for it, and wrote the rule in terms specific enough to quote back to an underwriter.
California built its version out of two documents working together. The statute narrows what a rate may be built from: Insurance Code § 1861.02(a) lists the insured’s driving safety record, the number of miles driven annually, the number of years of driving experience, and other factors the commissioner may adopt by regulation that have a substantial relationship to the risk of loss — in that order of importance.[4] The regulation then defines what can go into the first of those factors, and it does so with arithmetic: under 10 CCR § 2632.13(b), as amended operative December 11, 2011, a driver may be considered principally at fault only where the driver’s actions or omissions were at least 51 percent of the legal cause of the accident, and then only where bodily injury or death resulted or the total loss or damage exceeded $1,000.[8] A driver whose share of causation is 50 percent or less is, by that definition, not principally at fault at all.
Florida arrived at the same destination by a different road. Rather than narrowing the rating factors, it declared the surcharge itself an unfair method of competition. Section 626.9541(1)(o)3.a. of the Florida Statutes covers the imposing or requesting of an additional premium for a policy of motor vehicle liability, personal injury protection, medical payment, or collision insurance, or the refusal to renew such a policy, solely because the insured was involved in a motor vehicle accident — unless the insurer’s file contains information from which the insurer in good faith determines that the insured was substantially at fault.[6]
That last clause is the part worth sitting with, because it inverts the usual instinct. The Florida protection is not automatic; it is conditioned on what the carrier’s own file does or does not contain. A file with no investigation in it cannot support a good-faith determination of substantial fault. Reporting the crash, and giving your carrier the photographs, the police report number, and the witness names, is what fills that file with the version of events that favors you. Silence leaves the field to whatever the other carrier submits.
Statutory Survey
Surcharge Protections for the Not-At-Fault Driver
| Jurisdiction & Mechanism | What the Text Actually Says |
|---|---|
| California — the 51 percent line[4] | California Insurance Code § 1861.02(a) restricts what an auto rate may be built from: the insured’s driving safety record, the number of miles driven annually, the number of years of driving experience, and other factors the commissioner adopts by regulation that have a substantial relationship to the risk of loss. The regulation that defines the driving-record input draws the line at causation, not at involvement — 10 CCR § 2632.13(b) treats a driver as principally at fault only where the driver’s actions or omissions were at least 51 percent of the legal cause of the accident, and then only where bodily injury or death resulted or the total loss or damage exceeded $1,000. |
| Florida — the “substantially at fault” file test[6] | Florida Statutes § 626.9541(1)(o)3.a. defines as an unfair method of competition the imposing or requesting of an additional premium for a policy of motor vehicle liability, personal injury protection, medical payment, or collision insurance, or the refusal to renew the policy, solely because the insured was involved in a motor vehicle accident, unless the insurer’s file contains information from which the insurer in good faith determines that the insured was substantially at fault. The burden sits inside the carrier’s own file, which means the file has to say something — and it will only say something if the crash was investigated. |
| Florida — comprehensive and uninsured motorist coverage[6] | The same Florida section reaches further for two specific coverages. Section 626.9541(1)(o)10. names as an unfair practice the imposing or requesting of an additional premium for motor vehicle comprehensive or uninsured motorist coverage solely because the insured was involved in a motor vehicle accident or was convicted of a moving traffic violation. A driver who has to fall back on uninsured motorist coverage because the other driver had none is, in Florida, statutorily protected from being charged for that fallback. |
| Florida — the single at-fault accident[6] | Florida Statutes § 626.9541(1)(o)3.c. adds that an insurer may not fail to renew a policy if the insured has had only one accident in which he or she was at fault within the current three-year period. Note what this one covers: an accident the driver did cause. The not-at-fault driver is protected by subparagraph 3.a., which is the stronger of the two. |
| New York — the property-damage dollar threshold[7] | New York Insurance Law § 2335 bars an insurer from increasing the policy premium solely because the insured, or any other person who customarily operates a covered automobile, has had an accident that does not result in aggregate damage to property in excess of two thousand dollars — with a surcharge still permitted for any accident resulting in bodily injury, or where the insured has more than one accident in the merit rating experience period. New York draws its line at severity rather than at fault, so a small not-at-fault collision and a small at-fault collision are treated alike. |
| States without an applicable protection — read the filed rate plan | Where no statutory or regulatory protection applies to your situation, what governs is the carrier’s approved rating plan together with your state’s general insurance law, and that plan sets both the surcharge trigger and the length of the rating window. A filing may key the surcharge to a chargeable accident defined by fault, or to any claim with payment above a dollar threshold, or to claim frequency alone. The question to ask your carrier in writing is narrow and answerable: under your filed plan, is a claim on which you paid nothing and subrogated the full amount a chargeable accident? Because rating plans are filed with the state insurance regulator, that regulator — not the carrier’s service line — is where the filed answer lives. |
Where no statutory or regulatory protection applies to your situation, the governing documents are the carrier’s approved rating plan and your state’s general insurance law, and the vocabulary there is different: filings speak of a “chargeable” accident, which each carrier defines for itself and files with the regulator. That is why the useful question to ask is not “will this raise my rate” — a question no representative can answer without the claim being adjudicated — but whether, under the filed plan, a claim closed with a full subrogation recovery is a chargeable accident. Our research on whether your insurance goes up when someone hits your car works through how carriers actually score that event, and when car accidents fall off insurance covers the length of the rating window that follows.
Two Ways to Get the Car Fixed, and What Each One Costs
Calling your own carrier does not commit you to using your own coverage. These are separate acts: notice satisfies Part E, while filing a first-party claim is a choice you make afterward with full information. Understanding the difference between the two repair routes is what lets you make that choice rather than default into one.
The third-party route means presenting your damages to the at-fault driver’s liability carrier. Its attraction is obvious — no deductible, and, where the governing state’s damages law permits them, the rental car and the loss of value are on the table as ordinary damages rather than as policy benefits. Its weakness is structural, and it is visible in the first sentence of the ISO Part A insuring agreement: that carrier promises to pay damages for which its own insured becomes legally responsible, and to “settle or defend, as we consider appropriate, any claim or suit asking for these damages.”[1] As we consider appropriate. The pacing, the liability decision, and the valuation are all exercised by a company whose duty of good faith runs to the person who hit you.
The first-party route means presenting the same damage to your own carrier under Part D, which pays for direct and accidental loss to your covered auto, minus any applicable deductible shown in the Declarations.[1] Fault is not an element of that grant. Your carrier does not have to decide who caused the crash before it writes the check — it only has to decide that the loss happened and that the coverage is on the Declarations. That single structural difference is why the first-party route routinely produces a repaired car weeks before the third-party route produces an acceptance of liability.
Route Comparison
Third-Party Liability Claim vs. First-Party Collision Claim
| Point of Comparison | How the Two Routes Differ, and Why |
|---|---|
| Who you are asking for money[1] | Third-party route: the at-fault driver’s liability carrier, under a contract you are not a party to. Its promise under the ISO Personal Auto Policy Part A insuring agreement runs to its own insured — it will pay damages for bodily injury or property damage for which any insured becomes legally responsible because of an auto accident, and it will settle or defend, as we consider appropriate, any claim or suit asking for those damages. First-party route: your own carrier, under Part D, which pays for direct and accidental loss to your covered auto minus any applicable deductible shown in the Declarations. |
| What has to be proved first[1] | Third-party route: legal responsibility. Nothing is paid until the other carrier accepts that its insured caused the loss, and it is entitled to investigate before deciding. First-party route: only that the loss was direct and accidental and that Collision Coverage is shown in your Declarations for that auto. Fault is not an element of the Part D insuring agreement, which is the entire reason the first-party route moves faster. |
| What it costs you up front[5] | Third-party route: nothing. A liability settlement is not reduced by your deductible, because your deductible is a term of your contract and not of theirs. First-party route: the deductible, paid to the body shop out of your pocket at the moment you collect the car. It is recoverable later through subrogation, but the gap between paying it and getting it back is measured in months, not days. |
| The rental car while yours is in the shop[1] | Third-party route: where the governing state’s damages law allows a loss-of-use recovery, a rental is part of the damages the at-fault party owes, and the amount is negotiated with their adjuster. First-party route: the policy form is blunt about how thin the built-in benefit is. Transportation Expenses under Part D pays, without application of a deductible, up to a maximum of $600, and temporary transportation expenses not exceeding $20 per day, unless you bought a broader rental-reimbursement endorsement. Twenty dollars a day does not rent a car in 2026. |
| What happens if the other carrier stalls[2][3] | Third-party route: you wait, and your leverage is a complaint to the state insurance regulator. The NAIC Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act names as unfair practices the failure to acknowledge with reasonable promptness pertinent communications with respect to claims, the failure to adopt and implement reasonable standards for the prompt investigation and settlement of claims, and not attempting in good faith to effectuate prompt, fair and equitable settlement of claims submitted in which liability has become reasonably clear. Where a state has adopted the companion NAIC claims-settlement model regulation, those standards become clocks — acknowledgment of a claim notification within fifteen days, acceptance or denial within twenty-one days of properly executed proofs of loss, and a status letter every forty-five days while the investigation remains incomplete. First-party route: your own carrier owes you those duties directly, and it — not you — takes over the argument with the other side. |
| Who is standing between you and the other insurer[1] | Third-party route: nobody. You are negotiating the value of your own car against a professional adjuster whose duty of good faith runs to someone else. First-party route: your carrier pays first and then pursues the other side itself. Under the Our Right To Recover Payment provision, if we make a payment under this policy and the person to or for whom payment was made has a right to recover damages from another we shall be subrogated to that right — and the pursuit becomes the carrier’s job, funded by the carrier, on the carrier’s timetable. |
One consequence of the split is worth stating plainly because it surprises people who did nothing wrong. Where a vehicle is repairable but the repair is extensive, the resale value can drop even after a flawless repair, and the claim for that drop is usually pursued against the at-fault driver’s liability coverage rather than under your own physical damage coverage. Whether a first-party diminished-value claim is available against your own carrier depends on state law and on your policy language — Georgia is the best-known state where first-party diminished value is recognized — so this is a question to put to your own state’s insurance code rather than to assume. The same asymmetry governs a total loss: what the carrier owes under Part D is capped by the Limit Of Liability provision at the lesser of the actual cash value of the damaged property or the amount necessary to repair or replace it with other property of like kind and quality, with an adjustment for depreciation and physical condition made in determining actual cash value in the event of a total loss.[1] Our research on how insurers determine the value of a totaled car walks that valuation, and how long insurance pays for a rental car after an accident covers the gap that the $20-per-day transportation benefit leaves behind.
How the Deductible Comes Back
The single objection that stops most not-at-fault drivers from using their own collision coverage is the deductible. You did not cause this, and now you are handing a body shop $1,000 to release a car someone else damaged. The mechanism that reverses that is subrogation, and it is written into the same policy form.
Start with what the clause actually transfers. Under the Our Right To Recover Payment provision, if the insurer makes a payment under the policy and the person to or for whom payment was made has a right to recover damages from another, the insurer “shall be subrogated to that right.” That person must then do whatever is necessary to enable the insurer to exercise those rights, and nothing after loss to prejudice them.[1] In plain sequence: your carrier pays you, steps into your position against the other driver, and pursues the recovery with its own lawyers and its own money.
The companion paragraph handles the case where you collect twice. If the insurer pays and the person paid then recovers damages from another, that person must hold in trust for the insurer the proceeds of the recovery, and reimburse the insurer to the extent of its payment.[1] To the extent of our paymentis the ceiling. Damages above what the carrier paid — including your deductible, which by definition it did not pay — remain yours.
California put the deductible piece into regulation rather than leaving it to custom, and the text is unusually direct. Under 10 CCR § 2695.7(q), every insurer that makes a subrogation demand shall include in every demand the first party claimant’s deductible, and every insurer shall share subrogation recoveries on a proportionate basis with the first party claimant, unless the first party claimant has otherwise recovered the whole deductible amount.[5]
Follow the arithmetic that “proportionate” produces, because it is the part that surprises people. Suppose your carrier pays $8,000 after your $1,000 deductible, making the total demand $9,000. If the other carrier disputes fault and the matter resolves at 70 percent, the recovery is $6,300 — and the deductible share returned to you is 70 percent of $1,000, or $700, not the full amount. Your deductible is not senior to the carrier’s own loss under a proportionate rule; it rides alongside it.
The Clause Not to Trip Over
Once your carrier has paid, you owe it two things: whatever is necessary to enable it to exercise its recovery rights, and nothing after loss to prejudice them. Signing a private settlement or release with the other driver after your carrier has paid is precisely the prejudice that clause names. If the other driver offers you cash after a claim is open, the call goes to your adjuster before the pen comes out.
The Record Exists Whether or Not You Call
The unspoken premise behind “don’t call your own insurance” is that your phone call is what creates the record. It may not be. Auto claims are pooled in a shared claims exchange that member carriers both write to and read from, and the write is triggered by claim activity at a reporting carrier — not by which driver picked up the phone.
The Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner states the trigger in three verbs: if your insurance company starts, denies or pays out a claim, it will submit a C.L.U.E. report. The same page publishes the report’s fields — name, date of birth, policy number, date of loss, type of loss, the amount the company paid, a description of the covered property, and the vehicle information.[9] What that source establishes is the reporting insurer’s side of the transaction, not a universal rule about claimants. When the driver who hit you reports the crash to their own carrier and that carrier starts, denies or pays a claim, that activity can generate a claims-history record; whether anything attaches to you or to your vehicle depends on the reporting insurer’s practices and on how the database indexes the entry. So do not assume in either direction. Your free annual disclosure from the reporting agency is the only way to find out what, if anything, is actually there — and what staying silent reliably does accomplish is to keep your own carrier’s account of what happened out of the record.
The duration is set outside your carrier as well. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau describes LexisNexis C.L.U.E. as collecting and reporting up to seven years of auto insurance claims to help inform pricing and underwriting decisions for the insurance industry.[10] The outer federal ceiling is 15 U.S.C. § 1681c(a)(5), which generally bars a consumer reporting agency from including any other adverse item of information, other than records of convictions of crimes, which antedates the report by more than seven years — subject to the exceptions in § 1681c(b), which lift that limit for reports used in connection with certain high-dollar credit and life insurance transactions and certain employment decisions.[13]
What makes that bearable is that the entry is federally correctable, and the correction machinery is fast. Under 15 U.S.C. § 1681i(a)(1)(A), a consumer reporting agency must conduct a free, reasonable reinvestigation before the end of the 30-day period beginning on the date it receives notice of the dispute from the consumer — generally 30 days, extendable to 45 under § 1681i(a)(1)(B) where the consumer supplies additional relevant information during that initial period; under § 1681i(a)(2)(A) it must notify the furnisher within five business days; and under § 1681i(a)(5)(A) an item found inaccurate or incomplete, or that cannot be verified, must be promptly deleted or modified.[11] The carrier that reported the entry carries mirror duties under 15 U.S.C. § 1681s-2(b)(1) to investigate, review all relevant information the agency forwarded, report the results, and modify, delete, or permanently block an item it cannot verify.[12]
That is the practical argument for calling rather than staying quiet. A not-at-fault crash where your own carrier investigated, paid, subrogated, and recovered produces a file with a documented fault determination behind it. A not-at-fault crash you never reported produces whatever entry the other side’s carrier created. If what it says about the loss is wrong, the federal reinvestigation clock is the tool — and it is much easier to run when your own carrier’s file supports your version. Our research on what other car insurance companies can see in your claims history covers who queries that file and under what federal authority.
One Thing Neither Carrier Gets to Decide for You
Whichever route pays, an adjuster is likely to steer you toward a shop in the carrier’s own network. The referral is not improper on its face — network shops exist because they have agreed to rates and turnaround times — but in many states the choice of shop is yours, and some legislated that in terms you can quote. California, New York and Texas are the clearest examples below. Check your own state’s insurance code before assuming the same rule applies, and note that an anti-steering statute governs where the work is done, not how much the insurer has to pay for it — what the carrier owes still runs through your policy’s repair-cost and limit-of-liability terms.
California Insurance Code § 758.5 provides that no insurer shall require that an automobile be repaired at a specific automotive repair dealer; it permits a suggestion or recommendation only where the claimant expressly requests a referral or has been informed in writing of the right to select the repair facility, and it bars the insurer from suggesting a different dealer after the claimant has already chosen one.[14] New York Insurance Law § 2610(a) provides that where a collision or comprehensive loss has been suffered, no insurer providing that coverage shall require that repairs be made in a particular place or shop or by a particular concern, and § 2610(b) goes further, barring the insurer from even recommending or suggesting one unless expressly requested by the insured.[15] Texas Insurance Code § 1952.301 bars an insurer from limiting the beneficiary of the policy from selecting a repair person or facility, and applies the same bar to the settlement of third-party property damage claims — which means the at-fault driver’s carrier cannot dictate your shop either.[16]
The reason this matters more on a modern car than it did on a 2005 sedan is underneath the bumper cover. Forward-facing radar and camera modules are mounted to brackets behind fascias and windshields, and a repair that returns the panel to showroom appearance without re-aiming those sensors leaves a driver-assistance system pointing somewhere other than where the computer believes it is pointing. That is a post-repair calibration question, not a cosmetic one, and it is decided by the shop you choose. Our research on which car repairs you can claim on insurance covers the anti-steering statutes and the coverage line between collision damage and mechanical wear in more depth.
What to Do in the First Seventy-Two Hours
- Report the accident to your own carrier before anything is repaired. Give them how, when and where, plus the names and addresses of injured persons and witnesses — the exact facts Part E names. Say explicitly that you are providing notice and have not yet decided whether to file a claim, and ask them to confirm in writing how the contact was logged.
- Photograph the damage from six feet and from six inches, before the shop touches it. Part E entitles your insurer to inspect and appraise the damaged property before its repair or disposal. Your photographs are the backup if that inspection is delayed past the point the car has to move.
- Open the third-party claim with the other carrier in parallel, not instead. The two are not mutually exclusive, and nothing about notifying your own insurer forfeits the liability claim. If the other carrier accepts liability quickly and pays in full, you never use your own coverage and never pay a deductible.
- Decline the other carrier’s recorded statement until you have your own adjuster on the file. Your cooperation duty under Part E runs to your carrier, not to theirs. In a crash being examined for shared fault, a casual phrase about speed or following distance is the cheapest evidence the other side will collect all week.
- Ask your carrier one specific question in writing about the surcharge. Not “will my rate go up” but: under your filed rate plan, is a claim closed with a full subrogation recovery treated as a chargeable accident? Then check whether your state has a statute like California’s or Florida’s that answers it for them.
- If the other driver is uninsured, treat your own policy as the practical insurance route. Your own collision coverage, and uninsured motorist property damage coverage where your state offers it, are the mechanisms that actually pay for the car — bodily injury uninsured motorist coverage does not universally reach property damage, and collision is optional coverage you may not have purchased, so check your Declarations before assuming either is there. Part E adds a specific duty here: a person seeking Uninsured Motorists Coverage must promptly notify the police if a hit-and-run driver is involved. You can also pursue the driver personally, though what a judgment is worth against someone who could not afford insurance is a separate question. Our research on suing someone for hitting your car without insurance covers what a personal judgment is actually worth against an uninsured driver.
- Once the claim has closed, request your own claims-exchange disclosure and read what it says about the loss. You are entitled to a free report, and reading it is the only way to know what, if anything, was recorded. If an entry is inaccurate, dispute it with the consumer reporting agency rather than with your adjuster — the federal reinvestigation clock under 15 U.S.C. § 1681i(a)(1)(A), generally 30 days and extendable to 45 in the circumstances the statute specifies, starts only on notice to the agency.
If the collision happened while your car was parked and unattended, the reporting calculus shifts, because there may be no identified other carrier to claim against at all. Our research on whose insurance to call when someone hits your parked car covers that scenario directly.
Frequently Asked Questions
If the accident was not my fault, do I still have to call my own insurance?
Yes. Part E of the standard ISO Personal Auto Policy form PP 00 01 opens by stating that the insurer has no duty to provide coverage under the policy unless there has been full compliance with the duties that follow, and the first of those is that we must be notified promptly of how, when and where the accident or loss happened, including the names and addresses of any injured persons and of any witnesses. The sentence contains no reference to fault. The duty attaches to the accident, not to the blame. Carrier editions of the form vary, so read your own policy, and note that states differ on what a late report costs: many require the insurer to show the delay prejudiced it before coverage can be denied on that ground.
Will my premium go up if I report an accident that was not my fault?
In some states it legally cannot. California Insurance Code § 1861.02(a) limits auto rating to the insured’s driving safety record, annual mileage, years of driving experience, and other factors the commissioner adopts by regulation, and 10 CCR § 2632.13(b) treats a driver as principally at fault only where the driver’s actions or omissions were at least 51 percent of the legal cause of the accident. Florida Statutes § 626.9541(1)(o)3.a. makes it an unfair method of competition to impose an additional premium or refuse renewal solely because the insured was involved in a motor vehicle accident, unless the insurer’s file contains information from which the insurer in good faith determines that the insured was substantially at fault. Where no such protection applies, the answer comes from the carrier’s approved rating plan and the state’s general insurance law rather than from a code section.
How long do I have to report a not-at-fault accident to my insurer?
The policy word is "promptly," not a number of days. What gives that word teeth is the rest of Part E: a person seeking Coverage For Damage To Your Auto must take reasonable steps after loss to protect the vehicle from further loss and must permit us to inspect and appraise the damaged property before its repair or disposal. Every day between the crash and the call is a day the insurer loses its own inspection opportunity, which is the concrete prejudice a late-notice defense is built on. Report before the car is repaired, not after.
Can I just deal with the other driver’s insurance company directly?
You can, and you may still owe your own carrier notice anyway, because the Part E duty is not waived by the existence of a third-party claim. The structural problem with the third-party-only route is whose contract you are relying on. The ISO Part A insuring agreement obligates that carrier to pay damages for which its own insured becomes legally responsible and to settle or defend, as we consider appropriate, any claim or suit asking for those damages. Its duty of good faith runs to its policyholder. Nothing is paid until it accepts liability, and until then you are financing the repair yourself.
If I use my own collision coverage, do I lose my deductible?
You pay it up front and recover it through subrogation, at a rate that depends on how much the carrier collects. California regulates the mechanics explicitly: 10 CCR § 2695.7(q) provides that every insurer that makes a subrogation demand shall include in every demand the first party claimant’s deductible, and that every insurer shall share subrogation recoveries on a proportionate basis with the first party claimant, unless the first party claimant has otherwise recovered the whole deductible amount. Proportionate is the operative word — a 70 percent recovery on a disputed-liability claim returns 70 percent of the deductible, not all of it.
Does the accident go on my record even if I never call my insurer?
It can, because you are not the only party who can report it. The Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner states that if your insurance company starts, denies or pays out a claim, it will submit a C.L.U.E. report, and lists the report’s fields, which include date of loss, type of loss, the amount the company paid, and vehicle information. That describes the reporting insurer’s side of the transaction, not a universal rule about claimants. When the other driver reports the crash to their own carrier and that carrier starts, denies or pays a claim, that activity can create a claims-history record; whether and how anything attaches to you depends on the reporting insurer and on the database. Do not assume in either direction — request your own free disclosure and read it. What staying silent reliably does accomplish is to keep your own carrier’s version of events out of the file.
What if the other driver asks me not to involve insurance and offers to pay cash?
Treat the offer and the notice duty as separate decisions. You can accept a private payment and still satisfy Part E by notifying your carrier of how, when and where the accident happened — the duty is to report, not to file a claim. What makes the cash-only route risky is that it is priced before anyone has looked underneath. A bumper cover that looks intact can sit in front of a deformed energy absorber, a misaligned radar bracket, or a bent crash box, and the estimate that surfaces those items is written after disassembly, not in a parking lot. If a claim is already open with your carrier, do not sign a private release: the Our Right To Recover Payment provision requires you to do nothing after loss to prejudice the insurer’s recovery rights.
Can my insurer make me use its repair shop?
Not in the many states that legislated against it, though the rule is state by state rather than national and it governs where the work is done rather than how much the insurer has to pay for it. California Insurance Code § 758.5 provides that no insurer shall require that an automobile be repaired at a specific automotive repair dealer, permits a suggestion or recommendation only where the claimant expressly requests a referral or has been informed in writing of the right to select the repair facility, and bars the insurer from suggesting a different dealer after the claimant has chosen one. New York Insurance Law § 2610(a) provides that no insurer shall require that repairs be made in a particular place or shop or by a particular concern, and § 2610(b) bars the insurer from recommending one unless expressly requested by the insured. Texas Insurance Code § 1952.301 bars an insurer from limiting the beneficiary of the policy from selecting a repair person or facility, and applies the same bar to third-party property damage claims.
The other driver was uninsured. Does calling my insurer still help?
It is usually the only practical insurance route. A liability claim against an uninsured driver has no carrier behind it, so the demand runs at the individual personally — which you can do, though collectability is often the limiting factor. Your own collision coverage, and uninsured motorist property damage coverage where your state offers it, are the mechanisms built for this; uninsured motorist coverage does not universally reach property damage, and collision is optional, so check your Declarations for what you actually bought. and Part E imposes a specific extra duty where a hit-and-run driver is involved: a person seeking Uninsured Motorists Coverage must promptly notify the police. In Florida, § 626.9541(1)(o)10. separately bars an additional premium for motor vehicle comprehensive or uninsured motorist coverage imposed solely because the insured was involved in a motor vehicle accident.
Do I have to give the other driver’s insurer a recorded statement?
Your contractual cooperation duty under Part E runs to your own insurer — the obligation is to cooperate with us in the investigation, settlement or defense of any claim or suit, and to submit to examination under oath as often as we reasonably require. The other carrier is not "us." It has its own investigatory interest and a duty of good faith that runs to its policyholder, not to you. Where an accident is being examined for shared fault, an offhand phrase in a recorded statement is the cheapest evidence that adjuster will collect.
What if my carrier and the other carrier disagree about who was at fault?
That disagreement becomes their fight rather than yours, which is the practical value of the first-party route. Your carrier pays the covered loss and then steps into your shoes: under the Our Right To Recover Payment provision, if we make a payment under this policy and the person to or for whom payment was made has a right to recover damages from another we shall be subrogated to that right. Your duty from that point is narrow — do whatever is necessary to enable us to exercise our rights, and nothing after loss to prejudice them.
What does the policy pay for a rental car while mine is being fixed?
Under the base form, very little. The Transportation Expenses provision in Part D pays, without application of a deductible, up to a maximum of $600, and temporary transportation expenses not exceeding $20 per day in the event of a loss to your covered auto. Anything beyond that comes either from a rental-reimbursement endorsement you bought separately or from the at-fault driver’s liability carrier as ordinary damages, which is one of the few places the third-party route is plainly better than the first-party route.
Is there a downside to reporting a not-at-fault crash?
The honest downside is the record. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau describes LexisNexis C.L.U.E. as collecting and reporting up to seven years of auto insurance claims to help inform pricing and underwriting decisions for the insurance industry, and a not-at-fault entry sits there alongside every other loss. What the entry is not is uncontrollable: 15 U.S.C. § 1681i(a)(1)(A) requires a consumer reporting agency to conduct a free, reasonable reinvestigation within 30 days of receiving notice of a dispute — extendable to 45 days under § 1681i(a)(1)(B) where the consumer supplies additional relevant information during that period — § 1681i(a)(5)(A) requires prompt deletion or modification of an item that cannot be verified, and § 1681s-2(b)(1) imposes mirror duties on the insurer that furnished the entry.
Scope & Limitations
This report covers personal auto insurance in the 50 U.S. states and the District of Columbia. Policy language is quoted from the standard Insurance Services Office Personal Auto Policy form PP 00 01 06 98 as published by a state insurance regulator; individual carriers file their own editions and endorsements, and your own policy and Declarations page control. The dollar figures in the base form — the $600 transportation cap and the $20 daily limit among them — are the specimen values and are commonly amended by endorsement. National Association of Insurance Commissioners model acts and regulations have no force of their own; they bind an insurer only as adopted by a particular state, and adoption varies in both text and timing. The state provisions shown in the surcharge table are illustrative of the categories of protection that exist rather than a fifty-state compilation, and no-fault and add-on personal injury protection regimes, comparative and contributory negligence rules, total-loss thresholds, the enforceability of a notice clause as a condition precedent and whether an insurer must show prejudice from a late report, the availability of loss-of-use and diminished-value damages, the scope of uninsured motorist property damage coverage, anti-steering rules, and deadlines for bringing an action on a loss are all set state by state and are not resolved here. Two of the California regulations cited below are linked to an unofficial secondary reproduction, which the source directory identifies as such. Federal Fair Credit Reporting Act procedures are described as published in the U.S. Code. Verify current requirements against your state’s insurance code, your state insurance regulator, and your own policy before acting.
Legal Disclaimer
This content is provided for informational and educational research purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, insurance advice, or a coverage determination, and it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes, regulations, policy forms, and carrier underwriting rules change; verify current requirements with your state’s official code, your state insurance regulator, and your own insurer before taking any action.
Primary Source Directory
- Personal Auto Policy, ISO form PP 00 01 06 98 (Standard policy form published by a state insurance regulator): Nevada Division of Insurance. Part A Liability Coverage insuring agreement provides that the insurer will pay damages for bodily injury or property damage for which any insured becomes legally responsible because of an auto accident, and that “We will settle or defend, as we consider appropriate, any claim or suit asking for these damages,” with the duty ending when the limit of liability has been exhausted by payment of judgments or settlements. Part D, Coverage For Damage To Your Auto, pays for direct and accidental loss to your covered auto or any non-owned auto, including their equipment, minus any applicable deductible shown in the Declarations. The Part D Transportation Expenses provision pays, without application of a deductible, up to a maximum of $600, with temporary transportation expenses not exceeding $20 per day. The Part D Limit Of Liability provision caps recovery at the lesser of the actual cash value of the stolen or damaged property or the amount necessary to repair or replace the property with other property of like kind and quality, with an adjustment for depreciation and physical condition made in determining actual cash value in the event of a total loss. Part E, Duties After An Accident Or Loss, states that the insurer has no duty to provide coverage unless there has been full compliance with the listed duties, requires that “We must be notified promptly of how, when and where the accident or loss happened” together with the names and addresses of any injured persons and of any witnesses, requires a person seeking any coverage to cooperate in the investigation, settlement or defense of any claim or suit and to submit to examination under oath as often as the insurer reasonably requires, requires a person seeking Uninsured Motorists Coverage to promptly notify the police if a hit-and-run driver is involved, and requires a person seeking Coverage For Damage To Your Auto to take reasonable steps after loss to protect the vehicle from further loss and to permit the insurer to inspect and appraise the damaged property before its repair or disposal. The Our Right To Recover Payment provision subrogates the insurer to the paid person’s right of recovery, requires that person to do whatever is necessary to enable the insurer to exercise its rights and nothing after loss to prejudice them, and requires proceeds of a later recovery to be held in trust and reimbursed to the extent of the insurer’s payment. The Appraisal provision permits either party to demand an appraisal of the amount of loss.
- Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act, MO-900 (Official model act text): National Association of Insurance Commissioners, January 1997. Section 1 states that the purpose of the Act is to set forth standards for the investigation and disposition of claims arising under policies or certificates of insurance. Section 3 makes it an improper claims practice to commit an act defined in Section 4 where committed flagrantly and in conscious disregard of the Act, or with such frequency as to indicate a general business practice. Section 4 defines the unfair claims practices, including: knowingly misrepresenting relevant facts or policy provisions; failing to acknowledge with reasonable promptness pertinent communications with respect to claims; failing to adopt and implement reasonable standards for the prompt investigation and settlement of claims; not attempting in good faith to effectuate prompt, fair and equitable settlement of claims in which liability has become reasonably clear; refusing to pay claims without conducting a reasonable investigation; failing to affirm or deny coverage within a reasonable time after completing its investigation; and failing, in the case of claim denials or offers of compromise settlement, to promptly provide a reasonable and accurate explanation of the basis for such actions. A model act binds insurers only as adopted by a given state.
- Unfair Property/Casualty Claims Settlement Practices Model Regulation, MO-902 (Official model regulation text): National Association of Insurance Commissioners, July 1997. Section 4.A requires an insurer to maintain claim data that is accessible and retrievable for examination and to be able to provide the claim number, line of coverage, date of loss and date of payment of the claim, and date of denial or date closed without payment, for all open and closed files for the current year and the two preceding years. Section 6.A requires acknowledgment of a notification of claim within fifteen days. Section 7.A requires advising the first-party claimant of acceptance or denial within twenty-one days of receipt of properly executed proofs of loss; Section 7.B requires a status letter every forty-five days while an investigation remains incomplete; Section 7.F requires payment within thirty days of affirmation of liability where the amount is determined and not in dispute. A model regulation binds insurers only as adopted by a given state.
- California Insurance Code § 1861.02 — Rating factors (Official statute text): California Legislative Information, Office of Legislative Counsel. Subdivision (a) provides that rates and premiums for an automobile insurance policy shall be determined by application of the following factors in decreasing order of importance: the insured’s driving safety record; the number of miles he or she drives annually; the number of years of driving experience the insured has had; and those other factors that the commissioner may adopt by regulation and that have a substantial relationship to the risk of loss. Subdivision (b)(2) provides that the rate charged for a Good Driver Discount policy shall comply with subdivision (a) and shall be at least 20 percent below the rate the insured would otherwise have been charged for the same coverage.
- California Code of Regulations, Title 10, § 2695.7 — Standards for prompt, fair and equitable settlements (Secondary reproduction of regulation text): Fair Claims Settlement Practices Regulations, promulgated by the California Department of Insurance. The link below is to the Cornell Legal Information Institute, an unofficial secondary reproduction of the regulation, used here because the official California Code of Regulations publisher does not offer a stable public deep link to this section; verify the operative text against the official California Code of Regulations. Subsection (q) provides that every insurer that makes a subrogation demand shall include in every demand the first party claimant’s deductible, and that every insurer shall share subrogation recoveries on a proportionate basis with the first party claimant, unless the first party claimant has otherwise recovered the whole deductible amount. The regulation separately requires an insurer, upon receiving proof of claim, to accept or deny the claim in whole or in part immediately but in no event more than forty calendar days later, and to tender payment or otherwise perform its claim obligation immediately but in no event more than thirty calendar days after acceptance, with both time frames carving out automobile repair bills arising from collision and comprehensive policies subject to Section 560 of the California Insurance Code.
- Florida Statutes § 626.9541 — Unfair methods of competition and unfair or deceptive acts or practices defined (Official statute text): The Florida Senate, 2024 Florida Statutes. Subsection (1)(o)3.a. defines as an unfair method of competition the imposing or requesting of an additional premium for a policy of motor vehicle liability, personal injury protection, medical payment, or collision insurance or any combination thereof, or the refusal to renew the policy, solely because the insured was involved in a motor vehicle accident, unless the insurer’s file contains information from which the insurer in good faith determines that the insured was substantially at fault in the accident. Subsection (1)(o)3.c. provides that an insurer may not fail to renew a policy if the insured has had only one accident in which he or she was at fault within the current 3-year period. Subsection (1)(o)10. defines as an unfair practice the imposing or requesting of an additional premium for motor vehicle comprehensive or uninsured motorist coverage solely because the insured was involved in a motor vehicle accident or was convicted of a moving traffic violation.
- New York Insurance Law § 2335 — Prohibition of surcharges for certain accidents and traffic infractions (Official statute text): New York State Senate, Laws of New York. Bars an insurer authorized to transact or transacting business in the state from increasing the policy premium solely because the insured, or any other person who customarily operates an automobile covered by the policy, has had an accident that does not result in aggregate damage to property in excess of two thousand dollars — provided that a surcharge remains permissible for any accident that results in bodily injury, or where the insured has more than one accident in the merit rating experience period.
- California Code of Regulations, Title 10, § 2632.13 — Determination of principally at-fault (Secondary reproduction of regulation text): Promulgated by the California Department of Insurance. The link below is to the Cornell Legal Information Institute, an unofficial secondary reproduction of the regulation, used here because the official California Code of Regulations publisher does not offer a stable public deep link to this section; verify the operative text against the official California Code of Regulations. Subsection (b), as amended by rulemaking REG-2010-00011 operative December 11, 2011, provides that an insurer shall not determine that a driver is principally at fault for an accident unless the driver’s actions or omissions were at least 51 percent of the legal cause of the accident, subject to the presumptions in subsections (c) and (d), and either the accident resulted in bodily injury or death or, for an accident resulting only in property damage, the total loss or damage exceeded $1,000. The subsection adds that no determination made under the prior version of the regulation is affected by the 2011 amendment. The pre-2011 version of this rule stated the test at subsection (c), in terms of “proximate cause,” and applied a $750 threshold to the damage suffered by any one person; that superseded formulation still appears in older secondary summaries and should not be mistaken for the current rule. The California Department of Insurance document linked second is an official source confirming that the 2011 amendment raised the threshold from $750 to $1,000 and applied it to “total loss or damage” rather than to “any one person.”
- CLUE (Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange) (Official state regulator guidance): Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner. States that if your insurance company starts, denies or pays out a claim, it will submit a C.L.U.E. report; that the report generally contains up to seven years of personal-auto and personal-property claims history; that LexisNexis advises insurance companies not to report claims information when you contact them simply to ask a question about coverage or your deductible; publishes the report’s field list, including name, date of birth, policy number, date of loss, type of loss, amount the company paid, description of the covered property, and property address or vehicle information; and describes the dispute process, the 30-day notification of results, and the ability to add an explanation shown in all future reports.
- List of consumer reporting companies — LexisNexis C.L.U.E. & Telematics OnDemand (Official federal regulator listing): Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Describes C.L.U.E. as a claims information exchange collecting and reporting up to seven years of auto insurance claims, as well as seven years of home and personal property claims, to help inform pricing and underwriting decisions for the insurance industry; notes one free report every 12 months on request, availability of a security freeze, and a fifteen-day delivery requirement.
- 15 U.S.C. § 1681i — Procedure in case of disputed accuracy (Official statute text): Office of the Law Revision Counsel, U.S. House of Representatives. Subsection (a)(1)(A) requires a free, reasonable reinvestigation before the end of the 30-day period beginning on the date the agency receives notice of the dispute from the consumer or reseller; subsection (a)(1)(B) extends that period to 45 days where the consumer provides additional relevant information during the 30-day period; subsection (a)(2)(A) requires notification of the dispute to the furnisher before the expiration of the 5-business-day period beginning on receipt; subsection (a)(5)(A) requires prompt deletion or modification of an item found inaccurate or incomplete or that cannot be verified, and prompt notice to the furnisher; subsection (a)(6)(A) requires written notice of the results not later than 5 business days after completion.
- 15 U.S.C. § 1681s-2 — Responsibilities of furnishers of information to consumer reporting agencies (Official statute text): Office of the Law Revision Counsel, U.S. House of Representatives. Subsection (b)(1) requires a furnisher, after receiving notice of a dispute under § 1681i(a)(2), to investigate, review all relevant information forwarded by the agency, report the results, report any correction to the other nationwide agencies it supplied, and promptly modify, delete, or permanently block an item found inaccurate or incomplete or that cannot be verified; subsection (b)(2) ties the furnisher’s deadline to the agency’s § 1681i(a)(1) period.
- 15 U.S.C. § 1681c — Requirements relating to information contained in consumer reports (Official statute text): Office of the Law Revision Counsel, U.S. House of Representatives. Subsection (a)(5) bars a consumer reporting agency from including in a consumer report any other adverse item of information, other than records of convictions of crimes, which antedates the report by more than seven years. Subsection (b) exempts from that limitation reports used in connection with the transactions and employment decisions it specifies.
- California Insurance Code § 758.5 — Repair of insured vehicles (Official statute text): California Legislative Information, Office of Legislative Counsel. Provides that no insurer shall require that an automobile be repaired at a specific automotive repair dealer; permits a suggestion or recommendation only where the claimant expressly requests a referral or has been informed in writing of the right to select the repair facility; bars the insurer from suggesting a different dealer after the claimant has chosen one; and addresses limiting or discounting reasonable repair costs based on charges that would have been incurred at the insurer’s recommended dealer.
- New York Insurance Law § 2610 — Motor vehicle physical damage claims (Official statute text): New York State Senate, Laws of New York. Subsection (a) provides that whenever a motor vehicle collision or comprehensive loss has been suffered by an insured, no insurer providing that coverage shall require that repairs be made to the vehicle in a particular place or shop or by a particular concern. Subsection (b) provides that in processing any such claim, other than a claim solely involving window glass, the insurer shall not, unless expressly requested by the insured, recommend or suggest repairs be made in a particular place or shop or by a particular concern.
- Texas Insurance Code § 1952.301 (Official statute text): Texas Legislature, Texas Statutes. Provides that, except as provided by commissioner rule, an insurer may not directly or indirectly limit its coverage under a policy covering damage to a motor vehicle by specifying the brand, type, kind, age, vendor, supplier, or condition of parts or products that may be used to repair the vehicle, or by limiting the beneficiary of the policy from selecting a repair person or facility; and that in settling a third-party property damage claim, an insurer may not require the claimant to have repairs made by a particular repair person or facility or to use particular parts or products.