Research Summary
Who Pays, In Three Numbers
California requires drivers to carry only $5,000 in Property Damage Liability coverage — the lowest floor in the nation, and easily exhausted by a single modern bumper repair.
Once liability is affirmed and the repair amount is undisputed, the NAIC Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Model Regulation requires the insurer to tender payment within 30 days.
Michigan treats a safely parked car as stationary property. The striking driver’s Property Protection Insurance pays up to $1 million with zero deductible, regardless of fault.
What the Other Driver Was Legally Required to Do
Before either phone call gets made, it helps to understand what should have already happened at the scene. A driver who strikes an unattended parked car cannot legally just drive away — doing so converts an ordinary fender-bender into a criminal hit-and-run offense the moment the car leaves without complying with the state’s notification statute.
The driver is required to stop at the nearest safe location, make a genuine effort to find the vehicle’s owner, and — if no owner can be located — leave a securely attached, visible note listing their name, address, and the circumstances of the collision. California Vehicle Code § 20002 codifies this duty and makes fleeing a misdemeanor punishable by up to six months in county jail, a fine of up to $1,000, and two negligent-operator points on the offender’s driving record.[1] Texas Transportation Code § 550.024 imposes the identical duty, and grades the offense by dollar amount: a Class C misdemeanor if total damage is under $200, and a Class B misdemeanor — carrying jail time — once damage reaches $200 or more.[2] Pennsylvania treats the same act as a third-degree misdemeanor under Title 75 § 3743, carrying fines up to $2,500 and up to a year in jail.[3]
The same duty attaches even when no human was behind the wheel at the moment of impact. If a car rolls away because its parking brake was never engaged or a manual transmission was left in neutral on a slope, California law treats the owner exactly as if they had been driving — they must still locate the victim or leave a note, and willfully failing to do so carries the identical hit-and-run misdemeanor penalty.[1]
Path One vs. Path Two: The Fact That Decides the Call
Every parked-car claim narrows down to one branching question: is there an identified, insured driver on the other end, or not? The answer determines which company’s phone number gets dialed, which deductible applies, and whether the claim touches your own premium history at all.
Path One — Driver Identified & Insured
A note was left, or the driver stayed and exchanged information. Call their insurance company and file a third-party Property Damage Liability claim. No deductible, and your own premium is generally unaffected.
Path Two — Hit-and-Run or Uninsured Driver
No note, no driver, or a driver with no active policy. Call your own insurance company and file a first-party claim under Collision coverage or Uninsured Motorist Property Damage, subject to your deductible.
Path One: Filing Against the At-Fault Driver’s PDL
Property Damage Liability — commonly abbreviated PDL — is a mandatory coverage in almost every state, and it is the mechanism designed for exactly this scenario. It pays to repair the innocent party’s vehicle, cover a rental car during the repair, and replace destroyed personal property inside the car, all without the parked-car owner paying a deductible or absorbing a premium increase, because the claim runs entirely through someone else’s policy.
The catch is that every state caps how much PDL coverage a driver is legally required to carry, and that cap becomes the hard ceiling on what the at-fault driver’s insurer will pay — regardless of the actual repair bill.
State-by-State
Minimum Property Damage Liability (PDL)
| State | Minimum PDL Requirement |
|---|---|
| California | $5,000 |
| Delaware | $10,000 |
| Florida | $10,000 |
| Iowa | $15,000 |
| Illinois | $20,000 |
| Montana | $20,000 |
| Alabama | $25,000 |
| Arkansas | $25,000 |
| Georgia | $25,000 |
A driver carrying California’s $5,000 minimum who totals a parked vehicle worth $40,000 leaves a $35,000 gap between the repair bill and what their insurer is legally obligated to pay. The parked car’s owner does not simply absorb that gap — they turn to their own policy’s Underinsured Motorist Property Damage coverage or Collision coverage to close it, or pursue the at-fault driver personally in civil court for the difference.
Does It Matter If the Car Was Parked Illegally?
In the overwhelming majority of parked-car collisions, fault rests entirely with the moving driver — the law requires operators to maintain a proper lookout and navigate around stationary objects, and a parked car is treated as an existing circumstance the moving driver must account for, not an excuse. But a narrow exception exists when the parked vehicle itself created the hazard.
An illegally parked car can attract shared liability when its location actively contributes to the crash: blocking a travel lane or intersection, sitting on a blind curve or hilltop where it obscures sight lines, or resting on a high-speed shoulder without hazard lights engaged. A car parked in a fire lane or no-stopping zone is treated the same way, because those restrictions exist specifically to prevent the hazard that materialized.
Even then, the moving driver does not automatically escape liability. Courts apply the Last Clear Chance doctrine — even if the parked car was illegally placed, a moving driver who had a reasonable opportunity to see the obstruction and avoid it retains the final duty to do so. The South Carolina Supreme Court examined this exact balance in Suber v. Smith, weighing whether a driver failed to pull entirely off the roadway against the oncoming driver’s independent duty to keep a proper lookout.[6] A stationary object cannot cause a crash on its own; if the moving driver was speeding, distracted, or simply failed to react to a hazard they had ample time to see, fault typically stays with them regardless of the parking violation.
How much fault, if any, shifts to the parked car’s owner also depends on the state’s negligence framework. In strict contributory-negligence states such as North Carolina, even minimal fault for illegal parking can bar recovery entirely. In the comparative-negligence states that make up most of the country, fault is instead split by percentage — a parked car owner found 40 percent at fault for illegal parking on a $10,000 repair recovers $6,000, not zero.
Path Two: When There Is No Insurer to Call But Your Own
If the driver flees and is never identified, or the responsible driver is identified but carries no active policy, their PDL coverage is either nonexistent or unreachable. At that point, the claim has to run through the parked car owner’s own policy instead, and there are two coverages built for exactly this gap: Collision coverage and Uninsured Motorist Property Damage (UMPD).
Collision coverage is the more universal of the two. It pays to repair or replace the policyholder’s vehicle after a collision with another vehicle or object, regardless of who was at fault — which makes it the default tool for a hit-and-run against a parked car. The tradeoff is a mandatory out-of-pocket deductible before the insurer covers the rest of the bill. Because a legally parked car being struck is categorized as a not-at-fault event, filing a collision claim for it typically does not raise the policyholder’s premium.
UMPD is a narrower, sometimes cheaper alternative — where it exists. It is designed specifically to replace the PDL coverage an uninsured driver should have carried, and in some states it carries a lower deductible than collision, occasionally none at all. But its availability is a genuine patchwork: seven jurisdictions mandate it, roughly nineteen states make it optional, and the remaining states do not offer it at all, leaving collision coverage as the only fallback.
State-by-State
Uninsured Motorist Property Damage (UMPD)
| State | UMPD Status | Minimum Limit |
|---|---|---|
| District of Columbia | Mandatory | $5,000 |
| Vermont | Mandatory | $10,000 |
| Maryland | Mandatory | $15,000 |
| Virginia | Mandatory | $20,000 |
| South Carolina | Mandatory | $25,000 |
| North Carolina | Mandatory | $25,000 |
| West Virginia | Mandatory | $25,000 |
| California | Optional (offer required) | N/A |
| Illinois | Optional (offer required) | N/A |
| Texas | Not offered | N/A |
The hit-and-run scenario carries its own trap. In several states — including California, Illinois, Colorado, Georgia, Ohio, and Louisiana — state law expressly forbids using UMPD for property damage caused by an unidentified driver, because the coverage legally requires the at-fault driver to be identified and confirmed uninsured. A parked car struck by an unseen hit-and-run driver in Los Angeles cannot access UMPD at all; the owner is routed straight to collision coverage and its deductible.[7] South Carolina and New York add a second, separate requirement: verifiable physical contact between the vehicles, which blocks claims involving a “phantom vehicle” that forced a crash without ever touching the parked car.
Three States That Change the Rules Entirely
The two-path framework above holds in most of the country, but a handful of states run fundamentally different systems for parked-vehicle property damage.
Michigan treats a safely parked, unoccupied vehicle as tangible stationary property — legally identical to a fence or a mailbox — under Michigan Compiled Laws § 500.3121.[8] Every Michigan auto policy carries mandatory Property Protection Insurance (PPI), and when a moving driver strikes a parked car, it is the striking driver’s PPI that pays — with zero deductible, a flat $1 million coverage limit, and strict liability that pays out regardless of why the striking driver crashed.[9] That protection disappears only if the parked car itself was “unreasonably parked” under MCL § 500.3106 — a standard Michigan courts have interpreted narrowly, finding that being parked illegally alone (an expired meter, a no-parking zone) is not enough; the vehicle’s location must present a direct, unavoidable hazard.[10] [11]
New Yorkoffers a final safety net called MVAIC — the Motor Vehicle Accident Indemnification Corporation — for residents whose parked car is hit by a hit-and-run driver and who carry no collision coverage of their own. The deadlines are unforgiving: the accident must be reported to police within 24 hours, and a sworn Notice of Intention must be filed with MVAIC within 90 days of the crash. Missing either window generally disqualifies the claim, and if anyone in the victim’s household carries an auto policy, that policy must be exhausted first.[12]
Florida’s no-fault system only governs bodily injury through Personal Injury Protection — it has no bearing on parked-car property damage. A moving driver who strikes a parked car in Florida is held to ordinary tort liability, and their mandatory $10,000 PDL policy pays the repair bill, with the same gap-to-collision-coverage math applying above that limit.[13]
Documenting the Scene and the Insurer’s Legal Clock
Before dialing either number, the car should stay exactly where it is until photographs establish its position relative to curbs, parking lines, and any debris field. A search for a note, nearby witnesses, and business surveillance footage should happen next, since independent corroboration speeds up a claim that otherwise comes down to one party’s word.
A police report matters even for minor cosmetic damage, because most insurers require one to validate a claim — particularly a hit-and-run claim, where the report is the only official record establishing that a crime, not just an accident, occurred. Collisions in retail parking lots and apartment complexes sit on private property, and police may decline to dispatch an officer absent an injury, a suspected DUI, or a confirmed hit-and-run; most departments still allow a desk report or online report to satisfy the insurer’s documentation requirement.
Once a claim is filed, the insurer is bound by statutory timelines drawn from the NAIC Unfair Property/Casualty Claims Settlement Practices Model Regulation. The insurer must acknowledge receipt of the claim within 15 calendar days, and after receiving a proper proof of loss, has 21 days to accept or deny it. If more investigation time is needed, the insurer must say so in writing within that same 21-day window, then send a follow-up letter every 45 days thereafter. Once liability and the repair amount are settled and undisputed, payment is due within 30 days.[14] An insurer that blows through these deadlines without explanation exposes itself to regulatory action and accusations of bad-faith claims handling.
Why a “Minor” Parking-Lot Dent Now Costs Thousands
A cosmetic bumper scuff used to mean a few hundred dollars of sanding and filler. Today, most bumpers hide a network of ultrasonic sensors, cameras, and millimeter-wave radar behind the plastic cover — the hardware running blind-spot monitoring, rear cross-traffic alert, and automatic emergency braking. A low-speed impact that leaves only a surface scratch can still warp the radar mounting bracket behind that plastic; a sensor shifted by a single degree can cause a blind-spot system to stop detecting vehicles in the next lane entirely.
Manufacturers respond with strict, binding repair restrictions near any ADAS sensor zone, because plastic filler, reinforcement tape, and repainting all change the density the radar signal has to pass through cleanly.
OEM Position Statements
ADAS Bumper Paint-Thickness Limits
| Brand | Paint Limit | Restriction |
|---|---|---|
| Ford & Lincoln | 12 mils (300 microns) total topcoat | No body fillers or plastic welding near a radar zone. |
| Honda & Acura | 300 microns (200 preferred); 40-micron basecoat | No repairs permitted over Blind Spot Information sensor units. |
| Volkswagen | 150 microns | 25 cm clearance zone; no triple painting; no spot repairs. |
| Audi | 150 microns | 25 cm clearance zone; no filler; no spot repairs. |
| Mazda | Repainting prohibited over radar | Bumper must be replaced if the BSM module area is damaged. |
If a bumper is removed, repaired, or replaced at all, the sensors’ physical orientation has been disturbed, and the vehicle’s onboard computer needs a billable, discrete ADAS recalibration before those safety systems can be trusted again. Static recalibration happens indoors on a perfectly level floor using geometric target boards; dynamic recalibration requires a technician to drive the car at specific highway speeds for ten to twenty miles so the cameras relearn lane markings from scratch.[16] Between mandatory part replacement and recalibration labor, a parking-lot hit-and-run that only chips the paint can still generate a repair estimate running into the thousands of dollars — which is exactly why confirming whose insurance is paying, quickly, matters more than it used to.
Getting Your Deductible Back After a First-Party Claim
A parked car owner who pays a collision deductible because the driver fled or lacked insurance is not necessarily out that money for good. If the at-fault driver is later identified, the insurer pursues subrogation— legally stepping into the policyholder’s shoes to demand reimbursement from the at-fault driver or their insurer. If that recovery succeeds, the deductible is supposed to come back, but how much and how fast depends entirely on the state.
Pro-rata states such as California and New York require the insurer to refund the deductible in the same proportion as the overall recovery — recover 80 percent of the repair bill from the at-fault driver, refund 80 percent of the deductible.[17] States with strict “make whole” rules, including Washington and Wyoming, go further: the insurer cannot keep a single dollar of the recovery until the policyholder’s deductible is refunded at 100 percent.[18] Texas takes a procedural approach instead — insurers have roughly a year to actively pursue the at-fault driver or formally notify the policyholder in writing that they will not, freeing the policyholder to sue independently.[19]
Frequently Asked Questions
Someone hit my parked car — whose insurance do I call?
If the driver stayed or left a note with valid insurance information, call their insurer and file a Property Damage Liability claim — you pay no deductible. If the driver fled or has no insurance, call your own insurer and use your collision or uninsured motorist property damage coverage instead.
What if the driver who hit my parked car left no note and drove away?
File a police report first, since most insurers require one to validate a hit-and-run claim. Then file a first-party claim under your own collision coverage, which pays regardless of fault, or under uninsured motorist property damage coverage if your state permits it for unidentified drivers and your policy carries it.
Does my insurance go up if someone hits my parked car?
Filing a collision claim for a not-at-fault, legally parked vehicle typically does not raise your premium, because insurers code the event as zero-fault. It can still appear on your claims history (C.L.U.E./A-PLUS) for underwriting purposes even without a rate increase.
How long does an insurance company have to pay a parked car claim?
Under the NAIC Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Model Regulation, an insurer must acknowledge a claim within 15 days, accept or deny it within 21 days of receiving a proof of loss, and pay an undisputed, agreed amount within 30 days. States that have adopted the model regulation enforce these deadlines through their insurance departments.
Can I get my deductible back after my parked car is hit?
Only if your insurer successfully recovers money from the at-fault driver through subrogation, and the refund rules vary sharply by state. Pro-rata states like California and New York refund a percentage matching the recovery rate; "make whole" states like Washington and Wyoming require a full deductible refund before the insurer keeps anything.
Is my parked car owner's fault if it was illegally parked when it got hit?
Sometimes, but only if the illegal parking created an active hazard — blocking a travel lane, sitting on a blind curve, or obstructing sight lines. A car that is merely parked in a restricted zone without creating a hazard is still generally treated as a passive object the moving driver had the last clear chance to avoid.
Legal Disclaimer
This content is provided for informational and educational research purposes only. It does not constitute legal or financial advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Insurance coverages, statutory minimums, and claims procedures are subject to change and vary by policy; verify current rules with your insurer or your state’s department of insurance before relying on any figure in this report.
For Journalists & Researchers
Copy a formatted citation for this research report to use in articles, reports, or publications.
Primary Source Directory
- California Vehicle Code § 20002 (Official): State of California, hosted by Justia Law. Codifies the striking driver’s duty to locate the owner or leave a note after hitting an unattended vehicle, including the runaway-vehicle provision under subsection (b), and the misdemeanor penalties for fleeing.
- Texas Transportation Code § 550.024 (Official): State of Texas, hosted by FindLaw. Codifies the duty on striking an unattended vehicle and the Class C/Class B misdemeanor damage thresholds.
- Parked Car Accidents in Pennsylvania (secondary): Wilk Law Firm. Law-firm summary of Pennsylvania Vehicle Code Title 75 § 3743, describing the third-degree misdemeanor grading and penalties for leaving the scene of a parked-car collision.
- Minimum Liability Car Insurance: State-by-State Guide (secondary): Direct Auto Insurance. Consumer-facing compilation of state minimum Property Damage Liability requirements used in the comparison table above.
- Car Insurance Laws by State (secondary): FindLaw. Supplementary state minimum-coverage survey used to cross-check states not covered by the primary comparison source.
- Suber v. Smith (Official judicial opinion): South Carolina Supreme Court, hosted by Justia Law. Applies the Last Clear Chance doctrine to a collision involving a vehicle partially parked on a paved highway.
- Uninsured Motorist Property Damage (UMPD): 2026 Guide (secondary): WalletHub. Consumer guide compiling state UMPD mandates, optional-offer states, non-offering states, and the hit-and-run/phantom-vehicle carve-outs used in the table and discussion above.
- Michigan Compiled Laws § 500.3121 (Official): Michigan Legislature. Establishes Property Protection Insurance (PPI) and classifies a safely parked vehicle as tangible property.
- Property Protection Insurance vs. Property Damage Insurance (secondary/industry): Michigan Auto Law. Explains the $1 million PPI coverage limit, zero-deductible structure, and strict-liability payout mechanism.
- Michigan Compiled Laws § 500.3106 (Official): Michigan Legislature. Defines the “unreasonably parked” exception that strips a vehicle of PPI protection.
- The Parked Vehicle Exception — Michigan No-Fault Law (secondary): Lee Steinberg Law Firm. Summarizes Michigan appellate case law, including Wills v. State Farm and Autry v. Allstate, narrowing the “unreasonably parked” standard.
- What Happens If the At-Fault Driver Is Uninsured in New York? (secondary): Sternberg Injury Law Firm. Describes MVAIC’s role as a last-resort fund and its 24-hour police-report and 90-day filing deadlines.
- Florida Insurance Requirements (Official): Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles. Sets Florida’s $10,000 PIP and $10,000 PDL minimums and confirms PDL, not PIP, governs parked-vehicle property damage.
- Unfair Property/Casualty Claims Settlement Practices Model Regulation (Official): National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Sets the 15/21/30/45-day claim acknowledgment, coverage-decision, payment, and follow-up deadlines referenced throughout this report.
- Bumper Cover Repair With ADAS — Manufacturer Position Statements (Official/industry technical): I-CAR Repairability Technical Support (RTS). Position statements from Ford/Lincoln, Volkswagen, Audi, Honda/Acura, and Mazda governing paint-thickness limits and repair restrictions near ADAS bumper sensors.
- ADAS Recalibration After Collision Repair: Why It Matters (secondary): National Collision Authority. Describes static and dynamic ADAS recalibration procedures required after bumper repair or replacement.
- California Auto Subrogation Handout (secondary/legal industry): Matthiesen, Wickert & Lehrer (mwl-law.com). Describes California’s pro-rata deductible-reimbursement rule under 10 CA A.D.C. § 2695.7(q).
- Made Whole Doctrine in All 50 States (secondary/legal industry): Matthiesen, Wickert & Lehrer (mwl-law.com). State-by-state chart of subrogation “made whole” rules, including Washington and Wyoming’s full-refund-first standard.
- Deductible Reimbursement Chart (secondary/legal industry): Matthiesen, Wickert & Lehrer (mwl-law.com). State-by-state subrogation deductible chart, including Texas Insurance Code § 542.204’s one-year pursue-or-notify rule.