Research Summary
What the Record Shows About Horseback DUI
In State v. Dellinger (1985), the North Carolina Court of Appeals held that a horse ridden on a street by a rider with a 0.18 alcohol concentration is a “vehicle” under the impaired driving statute.
On June 10, 2024, Ohio’s Eleventh District Court of Appeals held that an Amish horse-drawn buggy is a “vehicle” under the OVI statute and affirmed the driver’s conviction.
Since 2023, North Dakota excludes a ridden animal from “vehicle” for its DUI statute and instead assesses a $200 fee for riding an animal while impaired to a hazardous degree.
Why the Answer Turns on the Word “Device”
A DUI prosecution has to fit the words of the statute. Each state’s law names the thing a person may not drive while impaired, and that word is the first gate. New York wrote “motor vehicle” into its DWI law, VTL § 1192, so the gate closes on anything without an engine.[2]North Carolina, Ohio, Arizona, Utah, Pennsylvania and Wyoming wrote the broader word “vehicle.”[11] [16] [19] [5] [9] [30]
The second gate is the definition of “vehicle,” and here those states sound almost identical. North Carolina’s version is typical: “Every device in, upon, or by which any person or property is or may be transported or drawn upon a highway, excepting devices moved by human power.”[12]A wagon fits that sentence easily, since it is a built object a horse draws along a highway. A saddle horse fits only if a living animal counts as a “device.” Utah’s Supreme Court said it does not: “No dictionary we have examined defines ‘device’ to encompass an animal.”[4]
Prosecutors have a second route that skips the definition. The traffic codes of New York, Pennsylvania, Ohio, North Carolina, Arizona and Wyoming each contain a section, which New York’s 1957 revision note traces to the Uniform Vehicle Code, giving a person riding an animal on a roadway “all of the duties applicable to the driver of a vehicle,” except provisions “which by their very nature can have no application.”[1] [3] [8] [17] The argument is that not riding drunk is one of those duties. The defense answer, which won in Utah and Pennsylvania, is that a criminal law cannot leave a rider to guess which parts of the traffic code apply.[4] [7]
The third route is a statute that answers the question outright. North Dakota and Wyoming legislators have both written bills about ridden animals and DUI, and Kentucky has a separate offense for impaired operation of a vehicle that is not a motor vehicle. Those are covered in the state section below.
Can You Get a DUI on a Horse? What Courts Have Held
North Carolina: yes. In State v. Dellinger(1985), the Court of Appeals took up what it called “an issue of first impression: whether a horse is a vehicle for the purpose of charging a violation of G.S. 20-138.1? We hold that it is.” The rider had been on a street with an alcohol concentration of 0.18. The court relied on a 1954 Kansas civil decision that treated a saddle horse as a vehicle for lighting rules, and on North Carolina’s animal-rider statute, G.S. 20-171. It also held that a horseback rider is an “operator” in “control of a vehicle which is in motion,” and found no error in the trial.[10] [13] [31]The current impaired driving statute still reaches a person who “drives any vehicle,” and the “every device” definition Dellinger construed is still in place.[11] [12]
Utah: no. On April 23, 1983, two men who had spent the afternoon drinking beer rode their horses down a Kaysville street. A woman riding behind one of them fell and suffered a severe concussion, and both men were convicted of DUI. In State v. Blowers(1986), the Utah Supreme Court reversed the conviction before it. It held that the “device” definition “cannot be legitimately read to include horses,” called the Kansas decision “a strained attempt to reach a desired result,” and struck the animal-rider statute as “a classic example of a criminal statute that is too vague in its prohibitions to survive due process challenge.”[4]Utah’s current DUI statute still turns on “a vehicle,” and its definition still begins with “a device.”[5] [6]
Pennsylvania: no. On April 7, 2002, State Police stopped two men riding horses on a public highway in Mercer County because they appeared intoxicated. The trial court dismissed their DUI charges, and in Commonwealth v. Noel(2004) the Pennsylvania Supreme Court affirmed, holding the animal-rider provision, 75 Pa.C.S. § 3103(a), unconstitutionally vague. The majority added that it is not clear “that a horse, which unlike a car is not fully controlled by the rider, would allow itself to be ‘driven’ in an unsafe manner.” Justice Eakin dissented in rhyme, arguing that an ordinary person “would know that riding a horse while intoxicated would be a violation.”[7] The text of § 3103(a) is still printed in the Consolidated Statutes, but Noel held it invalid.[8]
Ohio riders: no, at the trial level. In December 1995 a rider was charged with OVI after his horse and an automobile collided on a public highway. The Portsmouth Municipal Court in State v. Euton(1996) held that Ohio’s statutes “do not inform an individual of normal intelligence that riding a horse while under the influence of alcohol would violate R.C. 4511.19” and dismissed the case.[15]Euton is a trial-court ruling and binds no other court. Ohio’s appellate courts have since taken a broader view of buggies, covered in the next section.
Key Finding
The same “every device” definition produced opposite results: North Carolina’s Court of Appeals held in 1985 that a ridden horse is a vehicle for impaired driving, and Utah’s Supreme Court held in 1986 that it is not.
Can You Get a DUI on a Horse and Buggy?
In states whose DUI law says “vehicle,” a buggy is the easier case. Early on February 25, 2023, a motorist in Middlefield, Ohio reported an Amish buggy weaving over the center line. The officer who caught up found the driver slumped over and unconscious while the horses kept moving. He admitted drinking four Twisted Teas. In State v. Miller, decided June 10, 2024, the Eleventh District Court of Appeals reasoned that “an Amish buggy is a piece of equipment designed for transportation utilizing horses to ‘draw’ the ‘device,’” held that “any horse-drawn buggy” is a vehicle under the OVI statute, and affirmed a sentence of five days in jail followed by 18 days of electronically monitored house arrest, a fine and two years of probation.[14]
Arizona reached the same result decades earlier. In State v. Stewart(1941), the Arizona Supreme Court held that a charge of driving “a wagon and team” on Buckeye Road while intoxicated “states a public offense.” The 1928 code it applied went further than today’s, deeming a “ridden animal” a vehicle for rules of the road.[22]Even Utah’s Blowers opinion, which rejected the horseback charge, said that “horse-drawn carts fall within the accepted definition of ‘vehicles,’ while horses alone do not.”[4]
New York is the exception, because its gate is the word “motor.” In People v. Szymanski(1970), the driver of a two-horse stagecoach for a western-themed restaurant registered .25 on a breath test and was charged under § 1192. The court held that the statute’s limit to “motor vehicle” “was a deliberate legislative limitation” and that extending it is “for the Legislature of this State, and not this court.” It dismissed the charge.[1] Section 1192 still covers only a motor vehicle today.[2] The New York bicycle analysis that rests on the same case is in our report on DUI on a bike in New York.
Which States Allow DUI Charges for Riding a Horse?
The table lists the nine states where this research verified the statute text and, where one exists, the court decision. It is not a 50-state survey. States not listed have not been verified here and should not be read as allowing or barring a charge.
Verified States
How DUI Laws Treat Horseback Riders and Horse-Drawn Buggies
| State | DUI Statute Covers | Ridden Horse | Horse-Drawn Buggy | Sources |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| North Carolina | "Any vehicle" (G.S. 20-138.1) | Yes. State v. Dellinger (N.C. Ct. App. 1985) held a ridden horse is a vehicle | Not separately decided; G.S. 20-171 covers animal-drawn vehicles | [10][11][13] |
| Ohio | "Any vehicle, streetcar, or trackless trolley" (R.C. 4511.19) | No, at trial level. State v. Euton (Portsmouth Mun. Ct. 1996) dismissed the charge | Yes. State v. Miller (11th Dist. 2024) affirmed an OVI conviction | [14][15][16] |
| Arizona | "A vehicle" (A.R.S. § 28-1381) | Undecided. § 28-625 gives riders the duties in chapter 4, the DUI chapter; no modern case located | Yes under the 1928 code. State v. Stewart (1941) | [18][19][21][22] |
| Wyoming | "Any vehicle" (W.S. 31-5-233) | Undecided. § 31-5-107 gives riders driver duties; a 2026 bill to exclude ridden equines was not introduced | Undecided; no case located | [29][30] |
| Kentucky | "Motor vehicle" (KRS 189A.010); separate offense for "a vehicle that is not a motor vehicle" (KRS 189.520) | Undecided under KRS 189.520; no appellate case located | Covered by KRS 189.520 if the buggy is a "vehicle"; $20 to $100 fine | [26][27][28] |
| Utah | "A vehicle" (Utah Code § 41-6a-502) | No. State v. Blowers (Utah 1986) reversed a conviction | Blowers said horse-drawn carts fall within the accepted meaning of "vehicles"; not decided | [4][5][6] |
| Pennsylvania | "A vehicle" (75 Pa.C.S. § 3802) | No. Commonwealth v. Noel (Pa. 2004) held § 3103(a) void for vagueness | Not decided; § 3103(a), held void in Noel, is also the buggy provision | [7][8][9] |
| North Dakota | "Any vehicle" (N.D.C.C. § 39-08-01) | No. § 39-07-01(2) says a ridden animal is not a vehicle for the DUI statute; $200 fee instead | Not addressed by HB 1506 | [23][24][25] |
| New York | "A motor vehicle" (VTL § 1192) | No; a horse is not a motor vehicle | No. People v. Szymanski (1970) dismissed a stagecoach DWI | [1][2][3] |
North Dakota: Excluded by Statute in 2023
North Dakota had deemed a bicycle or ridden animal a vehicle for its traffic chapters. House Bill 1506, signed April 7, 2023, kept that rule for most of the code but carved out the DUI statute: “For purposes of section 39-08-01, a bicycle or ridden animal may not be deemed a vehicle.”[23] [24]The same bill created N.D.C.C. § 39-10.1-10, which bars riding an animal on a roadway or public area while impaired “to a degree which renders the individual a hazard to themselves or the general public” and sets a $200 fee.[25]
Wyoming: A 2026 Exclusion Bill That Was Not Introduced
Wyoming’s DUI statute applies to “any vehicle,” its definition covers “every device” by which a person is transported or drawn on a highway, and § 31-5-107 gives a person riding an animal on a roadway “all of the duties applicable to the driver of a vehicle.”[30]House Bill 0031, filed for the 2026 session as the “Saddles, not steering wheels act,” would have added that “‘Vehicle’ does not include horses, mules or other equines when ridden by a person” to the DUI statutes. The Legislature’s record shows the House did not consider it for introduction on February 13, 2026, so the current law is unchanged.[29]
Arizona: The Rider Statute Names the DUI Chapter
The New York, Pennsylvania and Wyoming animal-rider statutes refer generally to “this title,” “this part” or “this act.” Arizona’s is specific. A.R.S. § 28-625 makes a person riding an animal on a roadway subject to the duties of a driver “by this chapter and chapters 4 and 5 of this title,” and chapter 4 of Title 28 is titled “Driving Under the Influence.”[3] [8] [30] [18] [21]That specificity answers part of the vagueness objection that won in Utah and Pennsylvania. The defense still has two arguments: the DUI statute applies to a person who drives “a vehicle,” defined as “a device,” and § 28-625 excludes provisions that “by their very nature can have no application.”[19] [20] This research located no modern Arizona decision resolving it. The parallel bicycle provision is analyzed in our report on DUI on a bike in Arizona.
Kentucky: A Separate Offense for Non-Motor Vehicles
Kentucky’s main DUI statute, KRS 189A.010, covers motor vehicles. A separate statute, KRS 189.520(1), provides that no person under the influence “shall operate a vehicle that is not a motor vehicle anywhere in this state,” and orders officers to “enforce rigidly this section.” A violation carries a fine of $20 to $100.[26] [27]A buggy is the obvious target. Whether a ridden horse qualifies depends on Kentucky’s definition of “vehicle,” which includes “all agencies for the transportation of persons or property” on the public highways, and this research located no appellate decision applying it to a horse.[28]
Is It Illegal to Ride a Horse Drunk?
A ruling that DUI does not apply leaves the rider exposed to other charges and to civil liability. The Pennsylvania riders in Noel were charged with public drunkenness under 18 Pa.C.S. § 5505 as well as DUI; the appeal concerned only the DUI counts.[7]North Dakota’s $200 fee and Kentucky’s $20 to $100 fine apply specifically to impaired riding or impaired operation of a non-motor vehicle.[25] [27]
Civil liability is untouched by the criminal question. The New York court that dismissed the stagecoach DWI wrote that its ruling “does not mean that tortious acts of such drunken drivers are absolved from civil liability.”[1] The Utah case shows the kind of harm involved: a passenger fell from a running horse on a city street and suffered a severe concussion.[4]
The ordinary rules of the road can also follow the rider. The New York court that rejected the stagecoach DWI held that the animal-rider statute does apply the general traffic rules, listing signals, passing, lanes, turning, stopping, speed and parking.[1] Impaired riding on a private trail or pasture raises different questions, covered for cars in our report on drinking and driving on private property. For other machines that test the edge of DUI law, see DUI on a lawnmower.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you get a DUI on a horse?
It depends on the state. North Carolina's Court of Appeals upheld an impaired driving case against a horseback rider in State v. Dellinger (1985). Utah's Supreme Court in State v. Blowers (1986) and Pennsylvania's Supreme Court in Commonwealth v. Noel (2004) threw out horseback DUI charges, North Dakota excludes ridden animals by statute, and New York's DWI law covers only motor vehicles.
Is it illegal to ride a horse drunk?
Riding drunk can be illegal even where DUI does not apply. North Dakota assesses a $200 fee for riding an animal while impaired to a degree that makes the rider a hazard, Kentucky fines impaired operation of a non-motor vehicle $20 to $100, and the Pennsylvania riders in Noel were also charged with public drunkenness. A rider who causes a crash can also be sued.
Can you get a DUI on a horse and buggy?
In Ohio, yes: State v. Miller, 2024-Ohio-2217, held that a horse-drawn buggy is a "vehicle" under the OVI statute and affirmed the driver's conviction. Arizona's Supreme Court allowed a DUI charge for driving a wagon and team in 1941. New York is the exception, because its DWI statute covers only motor vehicles.
Which states allow DUI charges for riding a horse?
North Carolina is the state with an appellate decision treating a ridden horse as a vehicle for impaired driving. Arizona and Wyoming have animal-rider statutes that support a charge but no reported case. Utah, Pennsylvania, North Dakota and New York do not allow one, and Ohio reaches buggies but a trial court rejected a charge against a rider.
Why is a horse-drawn buggy treated differently from a horse?
Most states define "vehicle" as a "device" in, upon, or by which a person is transported or drawn on a highway. A buggy is a manufactured device that a horse draws. Courts in Utah and Pennsylvania have held that a horse itself is an animal, not a device.
Legal Disclaimer
This content is provided for informational and educational research purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. It covers selected U.S. states only, and court decisions described here may be limited or overruled by later cases or legislation. Consult a licensed attorney in your state about a specific charge.
For Journalists & Researchers
Copy a formatted citation for this research report to use in articles, reports, or publications.
Primary Source Directory
- People v. Szymanski, 63 Misc. 2d 40 (N.Y.C. Crim. Ct. 1970) (Official): Criminal Court of the City of New York, opinion text via Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project. Dismissed a DWI charge against the driver of a two-horse stagecoach because Vehicle and Traffic Law § 1192 reaches only a "motor vehicle."
- N.Y. Vehicle and Traffic Law § 1192 (Official): New York State Senate. New York impaired and intoxicated driving offenses, each written for a person who operates "a motor vehicle."
- N.Y. Vehicle and Traffic Law § 1105 (Official): New York State Senate. Gives a person riding an animal or driving an animal-drawn vehicle on a roadway the rights and duties of a vehicle driver.
- State v. Blowers, 717 P.2d 1321 (Utah 1986) (Official): Utah Supreme Court, opinion text via Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project. Reversed a DUI conviction for riding a horse: a horse is not a "device" and so not a "vehicle," and the animal-rider statute was void for vagueness.
- Utah Code § 41-6a-502 (Official): Utah State Legislature. Current Utah DUI statute, which applies to operating or being in actual physical control of "a vehicle" with a .05 alcohol concentration or while impaired.
- Utah Code § 41-6a-102 (Official): Utah State Legislature. Current Utah traffic code definitions; "vehicle" still means "a device in, on, or by which a person or property is or may be transported or drawn on a highway."
- Commonwealth v. Noel, 579 Pa. 546, 857 A.2d 1283 (2004) (Official): Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, opinion text via Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project. Affirmed dismissal of DUI charges against two horseback riders, holding the animal-rider provision, 75 Pa.C.S. § 3103(a), unconstitutionally vague.
- 75 Pa.C.S. § 3103: Persons riding animals or driving animal-drawn vehicles (Official): Pennsylvania General Assembly. The animal-rider provision Noel held void; its text remains in the Consolidated Statutes.
- 75 Pa.C.S. § 3802: Driving under influence of alcohol or controlled substance (Official): Pennsylvania General Assembly. Current Pennsylvania DUI statute, which replaced § 3731 in 2004 and applies to a person who drives, operates or controls "a vehicle."
- State v. Dellinger, 73 N.C. App. 685, 327 S.E.2d 609 (1985) (Official): North Carolina Court of Appeals, opinion text via Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project. Held that a horse ridden on a street is a "vehicle" under the impaired driving statute and found no error in the rider's trial.
- N.C. Gen. Stat. § 20-138.1: Impaired driving (Official): North Carolina General Assembly. Makes it an offense to drive "any vehicle" on a highway, street or public vehicular area while impaired or at 0.08 or more.
- N.C. Gen. Stat. § 20-4.01: Definitions (Official): North Carolina General Assembly. Defines "vehicle" in subdivision (49) as every device by which a person or property is or may be transported or drawn upon a highway, except human-powered devices.
- N.C. Gen. Stat. § 20-171: Traffic laws apply to persons riding animals (Official): North Carolina General Assembly. Subjects a person riding an animal or driving an animal-drawn vehicle to the provisions applicable to the driver of a vehicle.
- State v. Miller, 2024-Ohio-2217 (11th Dist.) (Official): Ohio Eleventh District Court of Appeals, via the Supreme Court of Ohio. Held that an Amish horse-drawn buggy is a "vehicle" under Ohio's OVI statute and affirmed the operator's conviction.
- State v. Euton, 77 Ohio Misc. 2d 19 (Portsmouth Mun. Ct. 1996) (Official): Portsmouth (Ohio) Municipal Court, opinion text via Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project. Dismissed an OVI charge against a rider whose horse collided with an automobile, holding that riding a horse while intoxicated does not violate R.C. 4511.19.
- Ohio Rev. Code § 4511.19 (Official): Ohio Legislative Service Commission. Ohio OVI statute, which applies to a person who operates "any vehicle, streetcar, or trackless trolley."
- Ohio Rev. Code § 4511.05 (Official): Ohio Legislative Service Commission. Subjects every person riding, driving, or leading an animal on a roadway to the traffic code provisions applicable to a vehicle driver.
- A.R.S. § 28-625: Persons riding animals or driving animal drawn vehicles (Official): Arizona State Legislature. Gives animal riders the duties of a driver under chapters 3, 4 and 5 of Title 28, except provisions that by their very nature can have no application.
- A.R.S. § 28-1381: Driving or actual physical control while under the influence (Official): Arizona State Legislature. Arizona DUI statute, which applies to driving or being in actual physical control of "a vehicle."
- A.R.S. § 28-101: Definitions (Official): Arizona State Legislature. Defines "vehicle" in paragraph 90 as a device in, on or by which a person or property is or may be transported or drawn on a public highway.
- Arizona Revised Statutes, Title 28 chapter index (Official): Arizona State Legislature. Shows chapter 4 of Title 28 is titled "Driving Under the Influence" and covers §§ 28-1301 to 28-1469.
- State v. Stewart, 57 Ariz. 82, 111 P.2d 70 (1941) (Official): Arizona Supreme Court, opinion text via Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project. Held that a charge of driving a wagon and team on a highway while intoxicated stated a DUI offense under the 1928 code.
- House Bill 1506 (2023), enrolled bill (Official): North Dakota Legislative Assembly. Removed bicycles and ridden animals from "vehicle" for the DUI statute and created a $200 fee for impaired riding. Signed April 7, 2023.
- N.D. Cent. Code § 39-07-01 (Official): North Dakota Legislative Branch. Deems a ridden animal a vehicle for chapters 39-08 through 39-13, except for the DUI statute, § 39-08-01.
- N.D. Cent. Code § 39-10.1-10 (Official): North Dakota Legislative Branch. Bicycling or riding an animal while under the influence; $200 fee.
- KRS 189.520 (Official): Kentucky General Assembly. Prohibits operating "a vehicle that is not a motor vehicle" while under the influence, with alcohol-concentration presumptions at 0.05 and 0.08.
- KRS 189.990: Penalties (Official): Kentucky General Assembly. Sets a fine of $20 to $100 for each violation of KRS 189.520(1).
- KRS 189.010: Definitions for chapter (Official): Kentucky General Assembly. Defines "vehicle" to include "all agencies for the transportation of persons or property over or upon the public highways."
- House Bill 0031 (2026), "Saddles, not steering wheels act" (Official): Wyoming Legislature. Would have excluded ridden horses, mules and other equines from "vehicle" in the DUI statutes; recorded February 13, 2026 as not considered for introduction.
- Wyoming Statutes, Title 31 (§§ 31-5-102, 31-5-107, 31-5-233) (Official): Wyoming Legislature. Current "vehicle" definition, the animal-rider duties provision, and the DUI statute.
- Conrad v. Dillinger, 176 Kan. 296, 270 P.2d 216 (1954) (Official): Kansas Supreme Court, opinion text via Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project. Civil case holding that a ridden saddle horse fell within the Kansas "vehicle" definition for lighting rules; relied on in Dellinger and rejected in Blowers.