Research Summary
What the Court Record Shows
The Sixth Circuit held that any reasonable officer would know a citizen who raises her middle finger engages in speech protected by the First Amendment.
In Cruise-Gulyas v. Minard, an officer pulled a driver over again less than 100 yards from the first stop after she flipped him off, and upgraded her ticket to speeding.
The Supreme Court denied the officer’s petition for review in Minard v. Cruise-Gulyas on October 7, 2019, leaving the Sixth Circuit ruling in place.
Why the Middle Finger Counts as Protected Speech
The First Amendment covers more than words. A gesture that carries a message, including an insulting one, is expression, and the government needs a recognized exception before it can punish it. The Supreme Court set the baseline for speech aimed at police in City of Houston v. Hill(1987), holding that the First Amendment “protects a significant amount of verbal criticism and challenge directed at police officers.”[2]
The same opinion explained why that matters: “The freedom of individuals verbally to oppose or challenge police action without thereby risking arrest is one of the principal characteristics by which we distinguish a free nation from a police state.”[2] Houston had made it a crime to interrupt an officer, and the Court struck the ordinance as overbroad because it reached ordinary protected criticism.
Federal appeals courts have applied that principle to the gesture itself. In 2019 the Sixth Circuit wrote that “any reasonable officer would know that a citizen who raises her middle finger engages in speech protected by the First Amendment,” relying on its own 1997 precedent and on Cohen v. California.[1]
Can a Cop Pull You Over for Flipping Them Off?
Cruise-Gulyas v. Minard answers that question with a traffic stop. In June 2017, an officer in Taylor, Michigan stopped Debra Cruise-Gulyas for speeding and, as a break, wrote her a ticket for a lesser non-moving violation. As she pulled away she raised her middle finger at him. He stopped her again less than 100 yards from the first stop and changed the ticket to a speeding violation.[1]
The court began its opinion this way: “Fits of rudeness or lack of gratitude may violate the Golden Rule. But that doesn’t make them illegal or for that matter punishable or for that matter grounds for a seizure.”[1]The legal reasoning ran in two steps. Any authority to hold her for speeding ended when the first stop ended, so the second stop needed new probable cause of a traffic violation or reasonable suspicion of a crime. The gesture supplied neither, because it “did not violate any identified law.”[1]
On the First Amendment claim, the court found an unjustified seizure plus a more severe ticket to be the kind of adverse action that would deter an ordinary person from speaking. It denied the officer qualified immunity — the doctrine that shields officers from personal liability unless they violate clearly established rights — and the Supreme Court declined to hear his appeal on October 7, 2019.[1] [6]
Case Law
Court Rulings on Gestures and Criticism Aimed at Police
| Case | What Happened | Ruling |
|---|---|---|
| Cruise-Gulyas v. Minard (6th Cir. 2019) [1][6] | Driver raised her middle finger as she left a speeding stop; officer pulled her over again and changed her ticket to a speeding violation | Second stop had no legal basis; the gesture is protected speech; officer denied qualified immunity at the pleadings stage |
| Swartz v. Insogna (2d Cir. 2013), as quoted in Cruise-Gulyas [1] | Middle finger directed at a police officer | “This ancient gesture of insult is not the basis for a reasonable suspicion of a traffic violation or impending criminal activity.” |
| Wilson v. Martin (6th Cir. 2013), as quoted in Cruise-Gulyas [1] | A girl extended her middle fingers at officers and walked away | The gesture “was crude, not criminal” and gave officers “no legal basis to order [her] to stop” |
| City of Houston v. Hill (U.S. 1987) [2] | Challenge to a Houston ordinance that made it unlawful to interrupt a police officer in the execution of duty | Ordinance struck as overbroad; the First Amendment protects a significant amount of verbal criticism of police |
Other circuits have reached the same result. The Sixth Circuit quoted the Second Circuit’s 2013 ruling in Swartz v. Insogna: “This ancient gesture of insult is not the basis for a reasonable suspicion of a traffic violation or impending criminal activity.” It also quoted its own 2013 decision in Wilson v. Martin, which called a girl’s middle fingers aimed at officers “crude, not criminal.”[1]
Where the Protection Ends: Fighting Words, Obscenity, and Disorderly Conduct
Protected speech has defined exceptions. Chaplinsky v. New Hampshire(1942) listed “the lewd and obscene, the profane, the libelous, and the insulting or ‘fighting’ words — those which by their very utterance inflict injury or tend to incite an immediate breach of the peace.”[3] State disorderly conduct statutes draw on these same ideas.
Later cases narrowed those categories. In Cohen v. California(1971), the Court held that obscene expression “must be, in some significant way, erotic,” and observed that “one man’s vulgarity is another’s lyric.”[4] A middle finger is crude, but the Sixth Circuit, citing Cohen, treats it as protected rather than obscene.[1]
State disorderly conduct statutes are where the risk lives. Pennsylvania’s, 18 Pa.C.S. § 5503, makes it an offense to make “an obscene gesture” with intent to cause public inconvenience, annoyance or alarm, or while recklessly creating that risk, and its definition of “public” includes highways. The offense is a summary offense, rising to a third-degree misdemeanor if the person persists after a reasonable warning or request to stop.[5] A gesture repeated after an officer tells you to stop, or paired with shouting, threats, or blocking traffic, gives an officer far more to point to than a single raised finger through a car window.
Key Finding
A middle finger alone does not give police reasonable suspicion or probable cause. The legal exposure comes from what accompanies it, such as threats, persisting after a warning, or conduct that fits a state disorderly conduct statute.
What Happens If You Flip Off a Cop Anyway
The cases above all reached court because an officer stopped, ticketed, or arrested someone first. A constitutional right is enforced afterward, through a motion to dismiss a charge or a civil rights lawsuit under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, the route Cruise-Gulyas used.[1] Neither one undoes the time spent on the roadside or in a holding cell.
The gesture also does nothing to an officer’s authority over real violations. If you were speeding, running with a dead taillight, or driving without your license on you, the officer can stop and cite you for that, and the court in Cruise-Gulyas noted that a stop needs only probable cause of a civil traffic violation.[1]
- Write down the details right away. Note the time, place, officer name or badge number, and what was said, including any reason given for a second stop.
- Keep the citation and any video. In Cruise-Gulyas the key fact was a ticket changed after the gesture, which the paperwork itself showed.[1]
- Contest the charge, not the officer, at the roadside.Arguing the First Amendment on the shoulder does not end a stop, and persisting after a warning is the conduct that raises Pennsylvania’s charge to a misdemeanor.[5]
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you legally flip off a cop?
Yes. Federal appeals courts treat the middle finger as speech protected by the First Amendment. The Sixth Circuit said in Cruise-Gulyas v. Minard (2019) that any reasonable officer would know a citizen who raises her middle finger engages in protected speech.
Can a cop pull you over for flipping them off?
Not for the gesture alone. A stop needs probable cause of a traffic violation or reasonable suspicion of a crime. The Second Circuit called the gesture no basis for reasonable suspicion, and the Sixth Circuit held a second stop over it unconstitutional.
Can you be arrested for flipping off a cop?
The gesture by itself does not violate any law identified by the courts in these cases, so it does not supply probable cause. An officer can still point to a broader offense such as disorderly conduct, and the risk rises when the gesture comes with threats, fighting, or persisting after a warning.
Can you get a ticket for flipping off a cop?
Not lawfully for the gesture. In Cruise-Gulyas, an officer who upgraded a driver’s ticket to speeding after she flipped him off was denied qualified immunity. A ticket for a real traffic violation you committed is a separate matter.
Can you go to jail for flipping off a cop?
Courts treat the gesture alone as protected speech, but an arrest and time in custody can come before any court rules on it. Pennsylvania’s disorderly conduct law, for example, names obscene gestures, and the charge can be a misdemeanor after a warning.
Legal Disclaimer
This content is provided for informational and educational research purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Federal appellate decisions bind only the courts in their own circuits, disorderly conduct statutes differ by state, and this report covers U.S. law only.
For Journalists & Researchers
Copy a formatted citation for this research report to use in articles, reports, or publications.
Primary Source Directory
- Cruise-Gulyas v. Minard, No. 18-2196 (6th Cir. Mar. 13, 2019) (Official): U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit. Held that a driver who raised her middle finger at an officer after a traffic stop could not be stopped again for the gesture, and that the gesture is speech protected by the First Amendment. Reported at 918 F.3d 494.
- City of Houston v. Hill, 482 U.S. 451 (1987) (Official): Supreme Court of the United States (via Cornell Legal Information Institute). Struck down a Houston ordinance that made it unlawful to interrupt an officer, holding that the First Amendment protects a significant amount of verbal criticism directed at police.
- Chaplinsky v. New Hampshire, 315 U.S. 568 (1942) (Official): Supreme Court of the United States (via Cornell Legal Information Institute). Defined the “fighting words” category of unprotected speech.
- Cohen v. California, 403 U.S. 15 (1971) (Official): Supreme Court of the United States (via Cornell Legal Information Institute). Reversed a conviction for wearing a jacket with a profane anti-draft message, holding that obscenity must be erotic and that the words were not directed at a particular hearer.
- 18 Pa.C.S. § 5503: Disorderly Conduct (Official): Pennsylvania General Assembly. Pennsylvania’s disorderly conduct statute, which lists making an obscene gesture with intent to cause public inconvenience, annoyance or alarm, and sets its grading.
- Docket No. 18-1435, Minard v. Cruise-Gulyas (Official): Supreme Court of the United States. Docket showing the officer’s petition for certiorari was denied on October 7, 2019.