Skip to content
Verified: November 2026

Car Insurance Research — Rental Car Claims

What Happens If You Damage a Rental Car (When You Have Insurance)?

Last Verified: November 2026Independent Research Report

A driver on a five-day trip declines the waiver at the counter because their own policy carries collision coverage with a $500 deductible. On day three the rental car backs into a light pole in a hotel garage, and the rear bumper and a parking sensor are crushed. The driver has insurance, so the repair itself is covered. What arrives over the following weeks is a claim from the rental company that lists more than the repair, a call from their own adjuster, and a question about whether any of it will show up on next year’s premium. So what happens if you damage a rental car when you have insurance?

You report it to the police and the rental company, and your insurer pays the repair minus your deductible. Loss-of-use, fee and diminished-value charges may still be yours.

Having coverage settles the largest number on the bill. The rest depends on which protection you used, the order in which each one pays, and the state where you rented, because three states sharply limit what a rental company can charge. The sections below follow a claim from the moment of impact to the renewal notice. If you have no personal policy, card benefit or waiver at all, the exposure is different and larger; that case is covered in our report on what happens if you damage a rental car without insurance.

Research Summary

What the Record Shows About Insured Rental Car Claims

$20 a Day
Standard Loss-of-Use Limit (1998 Form)

The 1998 ISO Personal Auto Policy pays loss-of-use expenses on a non-owned car up to $20 a day and $600 in total, without a deductible. The 2018 edition raised the limit to $30 a day and $900.

45 Days
Card Benefit Reporting Window

One Visa card benefit guide denies rental damage reported more than 45 days after the incident, and claims whose form is not received within 90 days.

3 States
Cap the Renter’s Bill

California, New York and Wisconsin statutes limit what a rental company can bill a renter after damage, and New York and Wisconsin bar loss-of-use and administrative fees outright.

What Happens If You Crash a Rental Car With Insurance: Step by Step

A rental car accident with insurance runs on two tracks at once. The rental company treats the damage as a breach of the rental contract and bills the renter. The renter’s insurer, card issuer or waiver then decides how much of that bill it absorbs. Each track has its own notice rules, and missing one can cost coverage on the other.

  1. Secure the scene and call the police when the law or the facts require it. Rental agreements commonly list failure to report an accident to the police and to the company as a violation that voids optional protections; Budget’s published terms are one example.[12] The standard personal auto policy itself asks for police notice only for theft and hit-and-run, but card benefits ask for a police report when one can be obtained, so a report helps every claim that follows.[1] [4] Our report on filing a car insurance claim without a police report covers the policy side in detail.
  2. Report the damage to the rental company before you return the car. Complete the company’s incident report, photograph the damage and the odometer, and keep copies of the initial and final rental agreements. Card benefit administrators list the accident report form, both agreements, photos, the repair estimate and the demand letter among the documents they require.[4]
  3. Notify your insurer promptly. Part E of the standard policy conditions coverage on prompt notice of how, when and where the accident happened, cooperation with the investigation, and letting the insurer inspect and appraise the damaged car before it is repaired or disposed of.[1] If another driver or a pedestrian was involved, your liability coverage also handles their claim.
  4. Open the card claim, if you paid with a card that has a rental benefit. Notice deadlines are short and separate from your insurer’s. One Visa guide requires the incident to be reported within 45 days, the signed claim form within 90 days, and the remaining documents within 365 days, and states that reporting to anyone else does not satisfy the requirement.[4]
  5. Receive the rental company’s damage claim. The demand typically combines the repair estimate with towing and storage, an administrative fee, a loss-of-use charge for the days the car is out of service, and sometimes a diminished-value charge.[16] In Wisconsin the company must give you and your insurer the chance to inspect the unrepaired car within 2 working days of notice; in New York you or your insurer have 72 hours to request an inspection.[10] [5]
  6. Send the claim to your insurer rather than paying it yourself. California and New York give an insured renter the right to require the rental company to submit its claim to the insurer, and bar the company from saying it will not deal with the insurer.[9] [5] The insurer and the company then settle the amount between themselves, and you remain responsible for whatever the policy does not cover.
  7. Pay your share and claim the remainder elsewhere.Your share is the deductible plus any charge your insurer declines. The insurer’s payment statement is what a secondary card benefit needs to reimburse those amounts.[4]

Which Coverage Pays First: Primary and Secondary

When several protections overlap, each contract says when it steps in. Coverage that is primary pays first regardless of other insurance; coverage that is secondary— also called excess — pays only what is left after the primary source responds. For damage to the rental car itself, the order usually runs as follows.

The counter waiver, if you bought it.A collision or loss damage waiver is not insurance. It is the rental company’s promise not to pursue you for damage to its car, and industry descriptions extend that promise to loss of use and related fees.[2] [16] With a valid waiver there is usually nothing for your insurer or card to pay, so no deductible and no personal claim. A waiver can be voided by contract violations such as an unlisted driver or impaired driving.[12] What the counter products cost, and which of them duplicate your policy, is covered in our research on rental car insurance cost per day.

Your personal auto policy, if you declined the waiver.A short-term rental is a “non-owned auto” under the standard form, and Part D pays for its damage under the collision and other-than-collision coverage you carry on your own car.[1]The form makes that coverage excess over “any other collectible source of recovery,” including coverage provided by the car’s owner, which is why an adjuster may ask whether a card, a travel plan or the rental company also responds.[1] Whether your policy reaches the rental in the first place, including the weight and business-use limits, is explained in does your personal car insurance cover rental cars.

A credit card benefit, usually second.Most card rental benefits are secondary in the cardholder’s home country. The Visa guide reviewed for this report reimburses the deductible on your auto policy plus any unreimbursed administrative and loss-of-use charges and reasonable towing, and it excludes expenses your insurer reimburses.[4]A smaller group of premium travel cards offer primary coverage, which lets you file with the card’s benefit administrator and leave your auto insurer out of the claim.[3] Every card benefit requires that the whole rental be charged to the card and that the counter waiver be declined, and none covers liability to other people.[4]

Travel insurance, as a separate layer. Travel plans with a rental car damage benefit reimburse collision, theft and weather damage up to a stated limit without involving your auto policy.[18] Their exclusions and how they coordinate with cards are covered in does travel insurance cover rental car damage.

Liability to other people follows a different order.The rental company carries its own fleet liability policy, and states decide whose policy pays first. California conclusively presumes the rental company’s policy is excess over the renter’s own insurance, and Florida presumes the rental company is primary unless the agreement shifts that role to the renter in 10-point type, which major rental agreements do.[14] [13]Across the states, the renter’s personal policy pays first in most documented outcomes.[15]

Do I Pay the Deductible on a Rental Car?

Yes, when your own policy pays. Part D of the standard form pays for loss to a non-owned auto “minus any applicable deductible shown in the Declarations,” and the deductible that applies is the one on your own collision or other-than-collision coverage.[1]On a $2,400 bumper and sensor repair with a $500 collision deductible, the insurer pays $1,900 and the renter owes $500. The deductible is the part of the rental company’s claim the insurer never pays, so the company bills it to the renter.

The payment is also capped by the car’s value. The form pays the lesser of the car’s actual cash value or the cost to repair or replace it with property of like kind and quality, so a totaled rental is paid at its pre-crash value minus the deductible.[1] Two ways around the deductible exist: a secondary card benefit reimburses it after the insurer pays, and a counter waiver avoids it because no personal claim is filed.[4] [3]

Loss of Use, Administrative Fees and Diminished Value

A rental company’s claim covers more than the body shop invoice because the company is a business that loses income while the car is off the lot. Three charges sit outside the repair, and personal coverage treats each one differently.

Loss of useis the rent the company says it lost during repair, often the daily rate multiplied by the estimated days out of service. The standard form does address it: in the 1998 edition, Transportation Expenses pay, without a deductible, loss-of-use expenses you become legally responsible for on a non-owned auto, but “the most we will pay for any expenses for loss of use is $20 per day,” within a $600 total, and only for the time reasonably required to repair the car.[1]The 2018 edition raised that basic limit to $30 a day and $900, so which figure applies depends on the edition, or the carrier’s own form, behind your policy.[19]Insurers often contest larger bills, and the Colorado Supreme Court case that settled the question in that state began when the renter’s insurer paid the repair but not a $228.76 loss-of-use bill; the court held the rental company could collect without proving it lost a rental.[11] How rental reimbursement and loss of use work on your own car after a crash is a separate question, covered in how long insurance pays for a rental car after an accident.

Administrative feescover the company’s cost of processing the claim. The standard form has no coverage part for them, so a personal claim generally leaves them with the renter.[1] Card benefits are written to pick up exactly this residue: the Visa guide reimburses unreimbursed administrative and loss-of-use charges, provided the rental company substantiates them.[4]

Diminished valueis the drop in the car’s resale value once it carries an accident history. The standard form limits payment to repair cost or actual cash value, which leaves no room for a resale-value charge, and the Visa guide excludes “diminished value” by name.[1] [4] For an insured renter without a waiver, diminished value is the charge most likely to remain unpaid by every policy.

Compare

Who Pays Each Rental Car Charge When You Have Coverage

How a standard personal auto policy, a secondary credit card benefit and a rental counter waiver treat each charge after rental car damage
ChargePersonal Auto Policy (ISO Form)Secondary Card BenefitCounter Waiver (CDW/LDW)
Repair of the rental car (or its value if totaled)Yes, under collision or other-than-collision coverage, up to the lesser of actual cash value or repair cost, minus your deductibleYour deductible, after the auto insurer paysWaived
Your deductiblePaid by youYes, the main thing a secondary benefit paysNot applicable; no personal claim needed
Loss of use (rent lost while the car is in the shop)Partly: the 1998 standard form pays up to $20 a day and $600 total ($30 and $900 in the 2018 edition), with no deductibleUnreimbursed portion, if the rental company substantiates itGenerally waived
Administrative or claim-handling feeNo provision in the standard formUnreimbursed portionGenerally waived
Diminished value (lower resale value after the crash)Not paid; the limit is actual cash value or repair costExcluded by nameGenerally waived
Towing and storageVaries by policy and claimReasonable towing to the nearest qualified repair facilityGenerally waived
Injuries and other people’s propertyYes, under your liability coverageNeverNever; that is supplemental liability, a separate product
Sources: ISO Personal Auto Policy PP 00 01 06 98; Navy Federal Visa Platinum Guide to Benefit (company terms, as of Dec. 31, 2024); NAIC; Auto Dealer Buzz (industry). Individual policies, card guides and waivers vary; your own documents control.Verified: November 2026

State Laws That Limit the Rental Company’s Claim

In most states the rental agreement alone sets what the company may bill. Three states write the limit into statute, which shrinks the residue an insured renter could be left with. New York caps an authorized driver’s liability at the lesser of the actual and reasonable repair cost or the car’s fair market value before the damage, and bars recovery of loss of use and related administrative fees.[5]Wisconsin uses a similar cap and bars loss of use, administrative charges including appraisal costs, and “any other charge” the statute does not permit.[10]

California’s limit is built from a list. A renter may be held to no more than estimated parts and labor, actual towing, storage and impound fees, and an administrative charge, with vandalism unrelated to theft capped at $500. Loss of use is not on the list. The administrative charge is permitted but capped by the size of the estimate, from nothing on a repair of $100 or less to $150 on one above $1,500.[7] [8] Because each of these statutes limits the total to listed items, a separate diminished-value charge does not fit within them as written.

New York adds a coverage rule on the insurance side. Policies covering fewer than five New York-registered private passenger vehicles must include, by endorsement, coverage for the insured’s obligation for actual damage to a rented vehicle “including loss of use,” for rentals of 30 continuous days or less anywhere in the United States, its territories or Canada.[6]A New York policyholder who damages a rental in Colorado, where loss of use is fully collectible, therefore has a policy obligated to respond to that charge, subject to the endorsement’s limits.

State Law

Rental Damage Limits in California, New York and Wisconsin

Renter liability caps, loss-of-use rules, administrative fee rules and insurer rights in three states
StateMost the Renter OwesLoss of UseAdministrative FeesInsurer’s Role
California [7][8][9]Estimated parts and labor at the company’s usual rates, plus actual towing, storage and impound fees; vandalism unrelated to theft capped at $500Not among the charges the statute allowsAllowed but capped: $0 if the estimate is $100 or less, $50 up to $500, $100 up to $1,500, $150 above thatRenter with confirmed coverage can require the company to submit the claim to the insurer
New York [5]Lesser of actual and reasonable repair cost or pre-damage fair market valueBarred from authorized driversRelated administrative fees barredInsured driver can require claims to go to the insurer; 72 hours to request an inspection
Wisconsin [10]Lesser of reasonable repair cost or fair market value, plus limited towing and storageBarredBarred, including appraisal costs; any other charge also barredRenter and insurer may inspect the unrepaired car within 2 working days of notice
Compiled from Cal. Civ. Code §§ 1939.03, 1939.05, 1939.07; N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law § 396-z; Wis. Stat. § 344.574. Applies to rentals in each state; other states not shown.Verified: November 2026

Will Your Insurance Go Up After Damaging a Rental Car?

A claim on your policy for a rental car is rated the same way as a claim for your own car. If you were at fault, it goes on your claims history and can raise your premium at renewal, which is the cost a renter accepts by relying on personal coverage instead of a waiver.[3] Our research on how much a car insurance surcharge is shows how insurers price an at-fault accident.

Two routes keep the claim off your auto policy. A counter waiver means the rental company absorbs the damage, and a card with primary rental coverage is filed with the card’s benefit administrator rather than your insurer.[3] A secondary card benefit does not, because it pays only after the auto insurer has handled the claim.[4] A liability claim from another driver or an injured person goes through your insurer in every case, since no card or waiver covers it.

Key Finding

An insured renter who declines the counter waiver owes the deductible unless a card benefit reimburses it, and usually owes any diminished-value charge personally. The 1998 standard auto policy pays loss of use only up to $20 a day and $600 in total ($30 and $900 in the 2018 edition).

Frequently Asked Questions

What happens if you damage a rental car with insurance?

You report the crash to the police and the rental company, then file with your insurer. Your collision coverage pays the repair minus your deductible. The rental company can still bill you for loss of use, administrative fees and diminished value, which personal policies cover only partly or not at all.

What happens if you crash a rental car and have full coverage?

Full coverage (liability plus collision and comprehensive) extends to most rental cars, so your insurer handles both the rental car repair and any injury or property claims from other people. You still owe the deductible, and the claim is treated like an accident in your own car when your premium is next rated.

Do I pay the deductible on a rental car?

Yes, if you use your own policy. The standard personal auto policy pays for damage to a non-owned car minus the deductible on your declarations page. A secondary credit card benefit usually reimburses that deductible, and buying the rental company’s waiver avoids it because no personal claim is filed.

Who pays first in a rental car accident when I have insurance?

For the rental car itself, the rental company’s waiver comes first if you bought it. If you declined it, your personal auto policy pays first and a standard credit card benefit pays what is left. For liability to other people, your personal policy is primary in most states, including by statute in California.

Does my car insurance pay the rental company’s loss-of-use charge?

Partly, at best. The 1998 standard ISO form pays loss-of-use expenses for a non-owned car up to $20 a day and $600 total; the 2018 edition raised the limit to $30 a day and $900. Insurers often dispute larger bills. California, New York and Wisconsin restrict or bar loss-of-use charges against renters, and New York policies must include rental coverage that covers loss of use.

Will my insurance go up if I damage a rental car?

It can. An at-fault rental car claim goes on your record like any other at-fault accident and can raise future premiums. A claim paid only by the rental company’s waiver or by a credit card with primary rental coverage is not filed with your auto insurer.


Legal Disclaimer

This content is provided for informational and educational research purposes only. It does not constitute legal, financial or insurance advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Policy forms, card benefit guides, rental agreements and state statutes vary and change; the ISO form quoted here is the 1998 edition (the 2018 edition raised the loss-of-use limit to $30 a day and $900), and your insurer’s current form may use different limits. This report covers U.S. law only. Verify terms with your insurer, card issuer and rental company before relying on a specific figure.

For Journalists & Researchers

Copy a formatted citation for this research report to use in articles, reports, or publications.

Primary Source Directory

  1. Personal Auto Policy, PP 00 01 06 98 (Official): Insurance Services Office form, hosted by the Nevada Division of Insurance. Standard personal auto contract. Part D pays for loss to a "non-owned auto" minus the deductible, up to the lesser of actual cash value or repair cost; Transportation Expenses pay loss-of-use expenses for a non-owned auto up to $20 a day and $600 total without a deductible; non-owned-auto coverage is excess over other collectible sources; Part E lists the duties after an accident.
  2. Auto Insurance (Official): National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Regulator consumer guidance on the rental counter products (collision or loss damage waiver, supplemental liability, personal accident, personal effects) and the personal coverage they can duplicate.
  3. Rental Car Insurance Guide: What Coverage to Consider (industry): State Farm. Insurer guidance that a renter relying on personal coverage pays the policy deductible and may see an at-fault claim raise future premiums, and on primary versus secondary credit card rental benefits.
  4. Your Visa Platinum Card Guide to Benefit: Basic Protection Package (Auto Rental Collision Damage Waiver) (company terms): Navy Federal Credit Union / Visa, benefit terms in effect as of December 31, 2024. Example card benefit terms: secondary to personal auto insurance in the renter’s home country, reimbursing the deductible plus unreimbursed loss-of-use and administrative charges and towing; renter must decline the counter waiver; excludes liability and diminished value; report within 45 days, claim form within 90 days, documents within 365 days.
  5. New York General Business Law § 396-z: Rental vehicle protections (Official): New York State Senate, Open Legislation. Caps an authorized driver’s damage liability at the lesser of actual and reasonable repair cost or pre-damage fair market value, bars recovery of loss of use and related administrative fees, lets an insured driver require that claims go to the insurer, sets a 72-hour window to request an inspection, and caps optional vehicle protection prices.
  6. New York Insurance Law § 3440: Rental vehicle coverage (Official): New York State Senate, Open Legislation. Requires policies covering fewer than five New York-registered private passenger vehicles to include, by endorsement, coverage for the insured’s obligation for actual damage to or loss of a rented vehicle, including loss of use, for rentals of 30 continuous days or less in the United States, its territories and Canada.
  7. California Civil Code § 1939.03 (Official): California Legislature. Lists the most a renter may agree to be responsible for: collision damage up to fair market value, theft only on proof of failure to use ordinary care, vandalism unrelated to theft up to $500, actual towing, storage and impound fees, and an administrative charge.
  8. California Civil Code § 1939.05 (Official): California Legislature. Caps a renter’s total damage liability at estimated parts and labor plus actual towing, storage and impound fees, requires discounts to be passed through, and caps the administrative charge at $0, $50, $100 or $150 depending on the estimate.
  9. California Civil Code § 1939.07 (Official): California Legislature. Requires damage claims to be reasonably related to the actual loss and lets a renter whose personal or business policy provides confirmed coverage require the rental company to submit the claim to that insurer.
  10. Wisconsin Statutes § 344.574: Limited liability for damage (Official): Wisconsin State Legislature. Limits a renter’s liability to the lesser of reasonable repair cost or fair market value plus limited towing and storage; bars loss of use, administrative charges including appraisal, and any other charge; and gives the renter and the renter’s insurer 2 working days to inspect the unrepaired car.
  11. Koenig v. PurCo Fleet Services, Inc., 2012 CO 5 (Official): Colorado Supreme Court, via Justia. Opinion holding that a rental company may recover loss-of-use damages without proving lost profits or full fleet utilization, in a case where the renter’s insurer had paid for the repair but not the loss-of-use bill.
  12. Rental Terms and Conditions (company terms): Budget Car Rental. Company rental terms making the renter responsible for damage to the car and voiding optional protections for listed violations, including failure to report an accident to the police and to the company.
  13. Florida Statutes § 627.7263 (Official): Florida Legislature, Online Sunshine. Presumes a rental company’s liability insurance is primary unless the rental agreement states, in at least 10-point type, that the renter’s personal insurance is primary.
  14. California Insurance Code § 11580.9 (Official): California Legislature, via FindLaw. Conclusively presumes that a rental company’s policy is excess over any other valid and collectible insurance available to the renter.
  15. Rental Car Company’s Liability Insurance Primary or Excess in All 50 States (secondary): Matthiesen, Wickert & Lehrer (MWL Law). Law-firm compilation of state rules on whether the rental company’s policy or the renter’s policy pays first.
  16. Rental Car Coverage: Diminution in Value, Loss of Use & Loss Damage Waiver (LDW), the Basics (industry): Auto Dealer Buzz. Industry explainer describing the loss damage waiver as the rental company’s agreement not to pursue the renter for damage, loss of use and related fees.
  17. Car Rentals and Collision Damage Waivers (Official): Wisconsin Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection. State consumer guidance explaining that a collision damage waiver is not insurance, that renters may inspect an unrepaired car within two days, and that personal policies need collision and comprehensive coverage to protect a rental car.
  18. Driving on Vacation: How Travel Insurance Can Help (industry): Generali Global Assistance. Travel insurer explanation of rental car damage benefits that reimburse collision, theft and weather damage up to a stated limit without involving the traveler’s auto policy.
  19. Personal Auto Policy, PP 00 01 09 18 (Official): Insurance Services Office form, hosted by the Virginia State Corporation Commission. The 2018 edition of the standard personal auto contract. Transportation Expenses pay up to a maximum of $900, and "the most we will pay for any expenses for loss of use is $30 per day."